Current total: 126 (final update: 11/5/08)
Brought to you by "Mugsy's Rap Sheet". EDITORS NOTE: Thank you all for spreading the word! The List became a minor underground sensation, with nearly 40,000 hits in the three short months of its' existence. I'd like to think we played some part in Barack Obama's victory on November 4th.
Sadly, it appears the "Obama Attacks" List is still needed, and will continue to be updated.
The List may have ended, but the story continues over on "Mugsy's Rap Sheet". I invite you to drop by and see what's new. - Mugsy MILESTONE! OCT 3RD: McCAIN SURPASSES HIS 100TH FLIP-FLOP/GAFFE/DECEPTION!
Way to go, Senator! We always knew you could do it! And with 32 days left to go till the election! Impressive!
We've added an RSS feed to easily keep tabs on when this page is updated!
Republican Presidential candidate Senator John McCain has become a Gaffe Machine since hitting the campaign trail last year. As the November election nears, the frequency and severity of his gaffes, flip-flops, and now outright deceptions, has grown to the point where I felt it necessary to have a MASTER LIST (with confirming links) of the multitude of missteps coming out of the McCain campaign all in one place. Seeing as what a big deal Republicans made out of Senator John Kerry's supposed "flip-flops" during the 2004 Presidential race, it only seems fair that we pay attention when their nominee for 2008 does the same thing.
Senator McCain alone is responsible for what comes out of his mouth, so in the interest of sheer manageability, I do not list "gaffes" or "flip flops" made on his behalf by campaign surrogates (such as Phil Gramm's infamous "nation of whinners" comment). I *did* include one comment by the Senator's wife Cindy, only because she criticized someone for saying something similar to what her own husband said.
I add items to the list as I find them or when you tell me about ones I missed, with corresponding links and credit to the site and/or person providing the item in question. I am continually working to improve the graphics and readability of the index, but with the gaffes flying at the rate of one new gaffe every other day, the list is growing SO fast, I barely have time to work on esthetics . I will update this index, adding past gaffes as I find them, as I continue to work on making it look nice.
Note: Mistakes are bound to happen maintaining such a huge list, so on the off-chance you catch the rare error, please let me know immediately. Thanks - Mugsy
Countdown: The McCain Double Talk Express
(June 30, 2008)
2008
Current total: 126
●
With a third spelling "mistake" in two days, instances of this "gaffe" now tracked separately.
●
November
2
●
Update to #9 in October. McCain campaign violates yet another music copyright, now for the SEVENTH time.
●
Despite requests, McCain's recent flurry of negative attacks upon Obama despite promising otherwise, can't be counted as a new flip-flop due to the McCain campaign having already launched its "first" negative attack ad all the way back in June.
●
Set background color to improve readability and reflect shifting tide in electoral map.
Now that AK Governor Sarah Palin is on the ticket and the McCain campaign has been forced to defend her, potential VP Palin's own flip-flops will be added to this list, but ONLY after the McCain campaign tries to refute/defend them.
●
Added missing gaffe from May 2nd suggesting Iraq war was over oil.
NEW FEATURE! Added an RSS feed to notify frequent visitors of updates! (Who knew when I started this list it would require special software just to keep up with all the updates?)
●
(President Bush goes on his annual August vacation while Congress is in recess; Senator Obama returns to his birthplace of Hawaii for his August break, resulting in a temporary slowdown in McCain gaffes.) - ADDENDUM:ABC News and MSNBC both noting that Senator McCain has not granted an interview since August 13 prior to the RNC Convention.
Correction: Changed references to McCain "canceling" a fundraiser at the home of Clayton Williams to "rescheduled". The fundraiser was not "canceled" but instead "moved" to another venue.
In response to the new Conservative meme that Senator Obama is receiving an unfair amount of positive press coverage, here is a new Master List of faux non-Controversies the Media hammered the Obama campaign with for months.
After being forced to respond to three separate incidents in recent weeks of conservatives alluding to Barack Obama's middle name, John McCain's campaign manager today sent a memo to top supporters urging them to stick to the campaign's preferred message -- and to avoid taking gratuitous shots at their Democratic rivals.
"Overheated rhetoric and personal attacks on our opponents distract from the big differences between John McCain's vision for the future of our nation and the Democrats," wrote Rick Davis in a document the campaign emailed to Republican officials and staffers this afternoon. "This campaign is about John McCain: his vision, leadership, experience, courage, service to his country and ability to lead as commander in chief from day one." - March 12, 2008
And to wrap up... "What if Senator Obama had made all these gaffes?"
Countdown -
11/03/08
November
Comment
link
Date
McCain on ANOTHER spelling gaffe???:
2.
Gaffe: Okay, we may need to start assuming this is no longer an "accident", but instead, just a clever way to get free advertising (and make you look like a moron in the process) to the point where individual instances need to be tracked:
McCain on Approving messages without spell checking them first:
1.
Gaffe: If this were the first time this had happened, or if it were not so close to Election Day when there is almost no margin for error, this gaffe would likely of gone unreported here.
As part of their final push of campaign ads in the days before the election,
Senator McCain "approved this message":
In an ad featuring Senator Obama's comment to "Joe the Plumber" that 'spreading the wealth around is good for everybody'., the ad then asks the question: "EVERBODY?"
Just last April, the McCain campaign released another video with the following typo:
Okay, now you're doing it on purpose. I'm being kind counting this as just one gaffe instead of three.
Ibid - Crooks & Liars
11/1/08
October
Comment
link
Date
McCain on bailing out the auto industry:
27.
Flip: In mid-October, McCain campaign economic adviser Carly Fiorina echoed Senator McCain's position that the U.S. government shouldn't... and is unlikely to... bailout the ailing U.S. auto industry:
"I don’t think the government can rescue the industry,” Carly Fiorina, former chief executive of Hewlett-Packard Corp, told Reuters at an event in suburban Detroit.”Whatever the government does, it should not take away the fundamentals of risk-taking. Sometimes it leads to rewards and sometimes consequences, downside,” she said. “In other words, the auto industry cannot be saved from its own bad bets."
Last June, Senator McCain himself spoke on bailing out any other industry in much the same way the Federal Government is bailing out Wall Street:
"Frankly I just don’t see a scenario where the federal government would come in and bail out any industry in America today."
Flop:In late October, Senator McCain appeared to be considering the possibility, telling NBC News that a limited bailout might be necessary if the current move by the Democratic Congress to rescue the ailing auto industry appeared to help:
"Let’s get the $25 billion to them to start with and see how that goes."
By Halloween, in an interview with ABC's "Good Morning America", Senator McCain was prepared to do "whatever needs to be done" to rescue the ailing auto industry:
Q: "We’re finding out that there may be a possibility of some sort of bail-out or government assistance for the auto industry. Would that be something that you would support?"
MCCAIN: "Well, we’ve already done that to $25 billion, and we’ve delayed getting them the money. I would do whatever I think needs to be done to help our automotive industry. We’ve got to make this transition to flex fuel, battery powered, hydrogen automobiles. And, obviously — and, also, I would provide tax credits for people who buy these new automobiles. We’ve got to keep this industry alive. There’s no doubt about that."
Deception: While campaigning in Defiance, Ohio, news reports broke of yet another quarter of record profits for Exxon/Mobile of $14.83 Billion dollars. Senator McCain responded to the news by saying, "[When I'm President,] we’re not gonna let that happen."
Flip: Following up on the "Socialist" meme Conservatives have been attempting to brand Senator Obama with, Senator McCain was asked during an interview with CNN's Larry King a question regarding the "graduated income tax" system we've been using for decades as a form of "spreading the wealth":
McCain: " Well, that’s spreading the wealth in the respect that we do have a graduated income tax. That’s a far cry from taking from one group of Americans and giving to another. I mean, that’s dramatically different."
(...)
Flop: King continued:
King: "Doesn't [sic] taxes pay for services?"
McCain: "Taxes pay for 'services'... Taxes pay to keep our government secure, to help those who can’t help themselves and other functions of government."
Gaffe: During a rally in Defiance, Ohio, Senator McCain interrupted his speech to give a shout-out:
"Joe’s with us today. Joe, where are you? Where is Joe? Is Joe here with us today? Joe, I thought you were here today."
But Joe "the Plumber" Wurzelbacher was not there. McCain campaign surrogates told ABC News it was "a simple mix up" and that Joe would be joining them at another appearance later that evening.
Flip: Following an absurd interview of Senator Biden by WFTV anchor Barbara West (where she used a popular Right-wing quote by Communist Leader Karl Marx to suggest Senator Obama might be a Socialist), the Obama campaign canceled a follow-up interview of Senator Biden's wife with the same reporter.
In an interview with Fox News' Sean Hannity, Senator McCain and his wife were incredulous that the Obama campaign would boycott WFTV, claiming the Obama campaign "pulls its advertising anytime someone asks "tough questions".
Flop: McCain himself has canceled numerous media appearances following difficult questioning or negative write-ups by reporters that would be conducting the interview (click here for links to examples).
Likewise, within days of selecting Alaska Governor Sarah Palin as his running mate, the McCain campaign declared that they would not make Palin available for interviews until the Media stops being "so tough on her".
Politico's Jeanne Cummings had a particularly salient response to that at the time:
Ibid
10/28/08
McCain on America's obligation to care for its citizens:
22.
Flip: During an interview with Fox's Sean Hannity, Senator McCain claimed it was a “far-left liberal view that you need to take money from one group of Americans and give it to another.”
Flop: Same breath. Senator McCain finished by saying:
"So the point is, yes, a society and government takes care of citizens who need our help. That’s what America is all about."
Despite being a vocal critic of "National Health care", Senator McCain himself has been a recipient of either "Socialized Medicine" or "Single Payer Health Care" his entire life (born on a military base in Ecuador, disabled in Vietnam, served in Congress since 1982). Also, despite his wife being worth over $100 Million dollars, Senator McCain still receives a monthly Social Security check worth $1,930 from a system he described as "broken".
McCain on incorrectly crediting Adviser Whitman as *founder* of eBay:
21.
Gaffe: Adviser to the McCain campaign, former eBay CEO Meg Whitman, was referred to by Senator McCain as being one of the "founders" of the famed online auction website:
"And next to him is a person well known to most Americans, Meg Whitman, the founder of EBay. I often like to repeat, 12 years ago, there was five employees, and now 1.3 million people around the globe making a living off of EBay."
The Huffington Post notes, “Whitman joined eBay as CEO in 1998, three years after it was founded by Pierre Omidyar, a Barack Obama supporter.”
Flip:On September 16th, a major flip-flop was recorded when Senator McCain, long the champion of "deregulation", suddenly cast himself as being highly "pro-regulation" following the finacial collapse on Wall Street, claiming to now recognize the need for... not just "reasonable" regulation, but "excessive" regulation... to guard against greed and reckless behavior by businesses without regard for the potential consequences.
Flop: Despite this, during a stump speech before Small Business Owners in Colorado Springs, CO, Senator McCain again proclaimed his strong support for "deregulation":
"They [small business owners] feel that what they need is lower taxes and less government regulation of their business"
So, while the lesson of the catastrophic economic meltdown on Wall Street due to unchecked corporate power and reckless behavior might have taught Senator McCain that having at least SOME checks on business might not be a bad thing, when it comes to Small Businesses... which account for 99.7% of all employers in the U.S.... apparently, the lesson is that small companies are too small to do any real harm... unless you happen to have more than one small business in your town.
Gaffe: During an interview with the local CBS affiliate in Washington, DC, Senator McCain challenged anyone to name "a single issue" he has changed his position on since he last ran in 2000:
"You’ll have to tell me what’s changed. I love it when they say, “Oh McCain has changed.” And I say, “What have I changed on?” They can’t name a single issue or they’ll name an issue and its false. I’m the same guy. I’m proud of our campaign. "
The senator made a similar comment last August (goto #15).
To be fair, the vast majority of McCain's "flip-flops" have been changes in his position just since the start of the current campaign.
Senator McCain's most notable flip-flops since 2000 include the need for "regulation" in the financial industry, the use of "Rovian" smear-campaign tactics (ditto June #14), whether or not a lack of "military service" should be considered a disqualification to be President (July #1), his support for "Immigration Reform" (June #20) & (May #1), off-shore drilling (June #12), privatizing Social Security (June #11), "Agents of Intolerance" (April #7), and tax cuts for the "wealthy" (Various #2)...all just since February.
On the other hand, McCain's continued belief in the existence of "Czechoslovakia" (July, #8 & #11) appears unchanged since 2000:
Flip: After Senator Obama inadvertently described his tax policy as a plan to "spread the wealth around", The McCain/Palin campaign has been accusing Senator Obama of advocating "Socialism":
"At least in Europe, the Socialist leaders who so admire my opponent are upfront about their objectives," McCain said in a radio address. "They use real numbers and honest language. And we should demand equal candor from Sen. Obama. Raising taxes on some in order to give checks to others is not a tax cut; it's just another government giveaway."
Gov. Palin, in a campaign appearance with Senator McCain in Reno, NV, accused Senator Obama of wanting to "redistribute the wealth":
"When it comes to taxes, you have a real choice on Nov. 4th. It's not negative, not mean-spirited... He's (Obama is) hiding his real agenda of redistributing your money."
Flop: (via ThinkProgress):
At an October 2000 town hall on MSNBC’s Hardball, an audience member asked Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) about why the rich pay higher taxes than the middle class. McCain defended progressive taxation, stating, “I think it’s to some degree because we feel, obviously, that wealthy people can afford more”:
[T]he very wealthy, because they can afford tax lawyers and all kinds of loopholes, really don’t pay nearly as much as you think they do when you just look at the percentages. […]
So, look, here’s what I really believe, that when you are — reach a certain level of comfort, there’s nothing wrong with paying somewhat more. … And frankly, I think the first people who deserve a tax cut are working Americans with children that need to educate their children, and they’re the ones that I would support tax cuts for first.
(This has to be Senator McCain's most hilarious gaffe yet.)
Gaffe: Pennsylvania Representative Jack Murtha, when talking about the political climate in parts of his state, was forced to apologize for the following comment on October 16th:
"There is no question that western Pennsylvania is a racist area."
Senator McCain, during a rally in Pennsylvania, in trying to criticize Rep. Murtha, flubbed his condemnation horribly, stating:
"You know, I think you may have noticed that Senator Obama's supporters have been saying some pretty nasty things about Western Pennsylvania lately. And you know, I couldn't agree with them more. [confused looks in audience] I couldn't disagree with you... I couldn't agree with you more than the fact that Western Pennsylvania is the most patriotic, most god-loving, most, most patriotic part of America, and this is a great part of the country."
Flip: Senator McCain was the exclusive guest of Fox News Sunday, October 19th, where he made the following criticism of Senator Obama's tax policy of raising taxes on the top 5% while cutting or maintaining the tax rate of the remaining 95%:
Host Chris Wallace: "Do you think that Senator Obama is a socialist? Do you think that his plans are socialism?"
McCAIN: "I think his plans are redistribution of the wealth. He said it himself, "We need to spread the wealth around." Now, that's one of..."
WALLACE: "Is that socialism?"
McCAIN: "That's one of the tenets of socialism. But it's more the liberal left, which he's always been on. He's always been in the left lane of American politics."
WALLACE: "But, Senator, when we talk..."
McCAIN: "So is one of the tenets of socialism redistribution of the wealth? Not just socialism — a lot of other liberal and left wing philosophies — redistribution of the wealth? I don't believe in it. I believe in wealth creation by Joe the Plumber."
Flop: The interview continues:
WALLACE: "But, Senator, you voted for the $700 billion bailout that's being used partially to nationalize American banks. Isn't that socialism?"
McCAIN: "That is reacting to a crisis that's due to greed and excess in Washington. And what this administration is doing wrong, and what Paulson is doing wrong, is not going out and buying up home loan mortgages, home mortgages, and giving people new mortgages at the new value of their home so they can stay in their home.
They're bailing out the banks. They're baling out these institutions."
WALLACE: "But you voted for that."
McCAIN: "Of course. It was a package that had to be enacted because the economy was about to go into the tank."
(EDITOR'S NOTE: To Senator McCain, asking the wealthiest Americans that have enjoyed an unfair tax advantage for the past eight years to pay their fair share so the working class Americans may pay less is "redistributing the wealth", but giving Working-Class Americans LESS of a tax cut in order to give the wealthy a bigger tax cut, ISN'T.)
(Senator McCain has flip-flopped on a lot of things during his campaign, but this has to be far-and-away his most indefensible.)
Flip: As noted back on September 1st, Senator McCain hired the same Republican smear-merchant, Tucker Eskew. that produced "robo-calls" back in 2000 for then-Governor Bush during the South Carolina primary suggesting to voters that McCain's adoptive Bengali daughter was actually the product of an interracial extra-marital affair.
At the time, back in 2000, Senator McCain denounced the practice, claiming "I promise you, I have never, and will never, have anything to do with that kind of political tactic."
Last May, while appearing on Fox's "The O'Reilly Factor", McCain said "[T]his campaign isn't going to be about Reverend Wright or Mr. Ayers. It's going to be about 'vision'. It's going to be about a plan of action for the American people who are hurting right now."
Flop: With less than a month to go till Election Day, the McCain campaign has begun utilizing pre-recorded robo-calls attacking Senator Obama on the subject of "Bill Ayers":
"You need to know that Barack Obama has worked closely with domestic terrorist Bill Ayers, whose organization bombed the U.S. capital, the Pentagon, a judges home, and killed Americans."
On "Fox News Sunday", Senator McCain defended the calls as "absolutely true" and "legitimate", questioning Senator Obama's "relationship" with Bill Ayers".
As noted below (#14), when Senator McCain "pals around" with "domestic terrorist G. Gordon Liddy", it is defensible because Liddy "served his time"... not for instructing listeners to his radio show on how to kill Federal Agents during the Waco siege... not for breaking into the office of psychiatrist Daniel Ellsberg or planning to fire bomb the Brookings Institute where Ellsberg's “Pentagon Papers” were stored... not for threatening to kill investigative journalist Jack Anderson... but for the break-in and attempted bugging of Democratic Headquarters in 1972.
Please note that the robo-caller is careful not to claim Ayers himself "bombed the U.S. Capitol, the Pentagon and a judges home", but the "organization" Ayers belonged to ("The Weather Underground")... which committed its crimes over 40 years ago when Senator Obama was eight years old.
By contrast, Senator McCain was 35 years old when Liddy was breaking into the Watergate building, 56 when Liddy was instructing listeners on "the proper way" to kill ATF Agents ("head shots" to circumvent their body armor), and 71 during his SIXTH appearance on “old friend” Liddy's radio show last May where he praised Liddy, saying:
“I’m proud of you, I’m proud of your family.” “It’s always a pleasure for me to come on your program, Gordon, and congratulations on your continued success and adherence to the principles and philosophies that keep our nation great.”
(Special thanks to "Grant in Texas" of "Mugsy's Rap Sheet" for the list of Liddy offenses and praise.)
McCain on Paling around with "questionable" characters:
14.
Flip: Repeatedly on the campaign trail, and again during the third presidential debate, Senator McCain made a point of questioning Senator Obama's "relationship" with former 60's radical and accused bomber William Ayers, pointing out how Obama once "attended a campaign fundraiser in William Ayers' home" in 1996.
Flop: After failing to appear on "The Late Show with David Letterman" back in September, McCain finally appeared on the show a month later where Letterman asked McCain about the "paling around with terrorist(s) William Ayers". McCain defended his attack as justifiable.
Letterman, in response, asked the Senator about his association with convicted felon G. Gordon Liddy, former lead Watergate burglar turned Right-Wing radio show host, who, in 1994 during the "Branch Davidian" siege in Waco, Texas, was explaining on his show "how to kill ATF agents". Not only had McCain appeared on Liddy's program no fewer than six times (most recently, last May), Letterman pointed out that McCain likewise "attended a fundraiser in Liddy's home".
McCain's defense of his relationship with Liddy: "He has served his time". Four-and-a-half years, to be precise.
Deception: During the third and final Presidential Debate, Senator McCain again brought up his running mate's (non-existent) natural gas pipeline that (supposedly) runs from Alaska to the lower 48: Also via ThinkProgress:
"Actually, last year, Palin opposed a plan to bring Alaska’s natural gas to the lower 48 states. This past summer, the Department of Energy issued an order allowing ConocoPhillips and Marathon Oil to to export 98.1 billion cubic feet of Alaskan natural gas — roughly the amount of natural gas used by 1.4 million families — to Asia. This had been the practice since 1969, since there were few alternatives to exporting.
However, as Time reports, “since this past May, some of Alaska’s gas could have wound up in domestic hands.” Sempra Energy opened the first Liquefied Natural Gas terminal on the West Coast of North America. The facility “is tied directly to the gas pipeline system that leads to California, Texas and Arizona.” However, Palin intervened with the DOE in April 2007, asking it to approve Conoco/Marathon’s exports to Asia."
Ibid
10/15/08
McCain on preparedness to be President:
12.
Gaffe: While addressing the crowd at a campaign rally in Virginia Beach, VA., Senator McCain suggested that the Presidency is no place for on-the-job training:
"The next President won’t have time to get used to the office. He won’t have the luxury of studying up on the issues before he acts."
Here is Senator McCain on his own readiness to be President:
– “I’m going to be honest: I know a lot less about economics than I do about military and foreign policy issues. I still need to be educated.” [Wall Street Journal, 11/26/05]
– “The issue of economics is not something I’ve understood as well as I should…I’ve got Greenspan’s book.” [Boston Globe, 12/18/07]
– “In the interest of full disclosure, I didn’t pay nearly the attention to those issues in the past…I was probably a ’supply-sider’ based on the fact that I really didn’t jump into the issue.” [The New Republic, 1/31/00
Last night (10/8/08) on Fox News, host Sean Hannity interviewed Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) and Gov. Sarah Palin (R-AK) and asked McCain what Palin’s role would be in his administration. McCain said Palin would be useful on energy issues — presumably because, as he has said before, “she knows more about energy than probably anyone else” in the U.S. As evidence, McCain claimed that Palin “was responsible for…a pipeline, the $40 billion pipeline bringing natural gas from Alaska down to the lower 48.”
The first section has yet to be laid, federal approvals are years away and the pipeline will not be completed for at least a decade. In fact, although it is the centerpiece of Ms. Palin’s relatively brief record as governor, the pipeline might never be built, and under a worst-case scenario, the state could lose up to $500 million it committed to defray regulatory and other costs.
Palin initiated the project by giving $500 million in Alaska state funds to TransCanada Corp. for the pipeline. However, the Canadian energy company “is not obligated to build it” and has made no promises to do so.
Moreover, some of Canada’s native tribes must approve the deal and those who live along the pipeline’s proposed route “complain they haven’t been consulted about it and are threatening to sue unless they are compensated.” One tribal representative has said that TransCanada has “very much downplayed the extent of the legal difficulties they face in Canada.”
But Palin has asked Alaskans to pray for the pipeline to be built, which is perhaps what the McCain-Palin campaign website means when it says that “work has begun on a $40 billion natural gas pipeline.”
Ibid
10/8/08
McCain on My Fellow Prisoners:
10.
Gaffe: During a rally in Pennsylvania, Senator McCain inadvertently addressed the crowd as "My fellow prisoners":
It has been a while since Senator McCain has made a reference to his experience as a P.O.W., and one might wonder if that subject was on his mind when making this gaffe.
(special thanks to reader Lou Ann C. for the reminder of this memorable gaffe.)
Gaffe: Probably deserving a label more severe than "gaffe", for the SIXTH time, a musical group has taken legal action to stop the McCain campaign from using their music without permission. This time, it is "Foo Fighters", complaining about the McCain campaign's use of their song, "My Hero":
“The saddest thing about this is that `My Hero’ was written as a celebration of the common man and his extraordinary potential,” the band said in a statement. “To have it appropriated without our knowledge and used in a manner that perverts the original sentiment of the lyric just tarnishes the song.”
The McCain campaign has been threatened with legal action five times before for using music without permission:
- at the conclusion of the GOP convention, Sen. McCain’s campaign blasted the song “Barracuda” by Heart. The tune is meant to be a theme song for Gov. Sarah Palin (R-AK), whose high school nickname was reportedly “Sarah Barracuda.” Heart’s representative issued the following statement:
"The Republican campaign did not ask for permission to use the song, nor would they have been granted that permission. We have asked the Republican campaign publicly not to use our music. We hope our wishes will be honored."
– In August, singer Jackson Browne sued the McCain campaign and the Ohio Republican Party for copyright infringement because his song “Running on Empty” was used in an ad by the state party. Browne’s lawyers said that “McCain and his campaign were well aware of” this fact
.– In August, the McCain campaign re-cut a web ad after comedian Mike Myers’s publicist complained about the use of footage of Myers and fellow Saturday Night Live alum Dana Carvey’s “Wayne’s World” characters
– Earlier this year, the copyright owners for the “Rocky” theme song “telephoned the McCain campaign" to politely complain it was being used without permission.
UPDATE (10/15): Rock supergroup Bon Jovi has ordered the McCain campaign to stop using their
song, "Who Says You Can't Go Home?" during Sarah Palin rallies. This marks the SEVENTH
time the McCain campaign has used copyrighted material without seeking the permission of the
artist first.
McCain on wasting money studying Grizzly Bear DNA:
8.
Flip: Senator McCain has cited on numerous occasions... including a TV commercial (that is no longer online)... one particularly egregious example of "wasteful government spending" involving the study of "grizzly bear DNA":
"Three million to study the DNA of bears in Montana. Unbelievable.
I don't know if it was a paternity issue or criminal," he joked, "but it was a waste of money."
Flop: The commercial was taken offline when it was discovered that Senator McCain actually voted FOR the bill containing the grizzly DNA study."
Flip: In his opening response during the second Presidential Debate, Senator McCain unveiled a stunning new plan for "the Federal Government to buy up millions of failed mortgages" (7:15 in the video) that would then be "renegotiated" with the defaulted home owner, in effect "nationalizing" the home mortgage market and turning the Federal Government into the lender of last resort. According to a 1-1/2 page McCain campaign "fact sheet", the plan would cost an additional "$300 Billion dollars" (in addition to the current $700 Billion dollar bailout, two wars, retaining the Bush tax cuts and cutting corporate taxes even further )
Flop: Later, Senator McCain went on to chastise Senator Obama for "obscene spending", ridiculing him several times for (among other things) approving a "$3 million dollar projector" for "an Illinois Community Center."
McCain on government bailing out "reckless borrowers":
6.
Flip:On several occasions, Senator McCain has cited on the campaign trail that he does not believe it is the job of government to bailout reckless borrowers:
"Some Americans bought homes they couldn't afford, betting that rising prices would make it easier to refinance later at more affordable rates," he said. Later he added that "any assistance must be temporary and must not reward people who were irresponsible at the expense of those who weren't."
Flop: During the second Presidential debate, Senator McCain announced a massive new plan (advance video to 7:15) for the Federal Government to "buy up millions of foreclosed mortgages" that would then be "renegotiated" with the defaulted home owner, in essence, making the Federal Government a "lender of last resort", permanently bailing out millions of Americans... some of whom McCain himself would certainly deem "irresponsible".
Gaffe: Back in November of 2005, Senator McCain made the following comment during an interview with Wall Street Journal reporter Steven Moore that has haunts him to this day:
"I'm going to be honest: I know a lot less about economics than I do about military and foreign policy issues. I still need to be educated."
And again
in December of 2007 to a reporter from the Baltimore Sun:
"The issue of economics is something that I've really never understood as well as I should. I understand the basics, the fundamentals, the vision, all that kind of stuff,'' he said. "But I would like to have someone I'm close to that really is a good strong economist. As long as Alan Greenspan is around I would certainly use him for advice and counsel."
On October 3rd, 32 days till the election, McCain catches himself in mid-sentence making the same mistake. During a radio interview with the Denver Post, Senator McCain tries to explain his voting Yes on the market bailout bill, earmarks and all, despite saying that a bill containing earmarks would be "unacceptable" (see flip-flop #3 below):
...before cutting himself off. Seeming to realize that he was once again admitting he doesn’t understand the economy, McCain corrected himself saying, “I mean, ‘We have to understand how serious this is.’”
Flip: On Oct 1st, in an interview with Fox News’s Carl Cameron, Senator McCain claimed that he "does not complain about the Media":
McCAIN: "I do not comment on the media treatment of me or Sarah. Complaining about something we are doing voluntarily that we want to do and get done I think would just not be productive. […] But I do not complain about the media and I will not complain because that’s not appropriate for me to do so and frankly it doesn’t do me any good if I did."
And while members of the McCain campaign DO criticize the Media regularly, McCain himself has been rather subdued when it comes to direct criticism of the media's treatment of him and his campaign.
Flop: The next day, Senator McCain told the crowd during a Denver Town Hall meeting, not only does he personally bash the media on a regular basis, but that he enjoys it:
McCAIN: "I do believe that there are many occasions where the nature of the media is to exaggerate things and perhaps not be as accurate as we would like them to be. […] I love to bash the media all the time."
McCain on voting for an "unacceptable" bailout bill:
3.
Flip: On September 23rd, in an interview with CNN's Wolf Blitzer, Senator McCain... who has made "earmark reform" a hallmark of his campaign... said that voting for a market bailout bill that included earmarks would be "unacceptable". Within the bill Congress was was now seeking to pass, a number of special interest earmarks were added to make the bill more appealing to members of the House and Senate that had previously voted "No" on an earlier version this past week... earmarks that include: excising a 39cent tax on wooden arrows made for children, tax breaks for race-track owners, and Rum imported from Puerto Rico.
Flop: October 3rd, McCain votes for the market bailout bill, pork and all.
McCain on renegotiating the Colorado River Compact:
2.
Deception: During an Oct. 2nd interview with the Denver Post, Senator McCain made the following claim:
McCAIN: "And by the way, whatever misinterpretation there may have been, I will not and have never supported renegotiating the Colorado River Compact. … Never, Never would I support a renegotiation of the Colorado River Compact. Please. No. Got it?"
Senator McCain probably should have thought more about why he was even being asked the question because, just two months earlier , when discussing the issue with a Pueblo Indian Chieftain, McCain made the following claim:
McCAIN: "I don’t think there’s any doubt the major, major issue is water and can be as important as oil. So the compact that is in effect, obviously, needs to be renegotiated over time amongst the interested parties."
"If this were a dictatorship, it would be a heck of a lot easier, just so long as I’m the dictator."
Today, while discussing the Wall Street bailout package approved by Congress, Senator McCain criticized Congress for failing to pass a bill the day before:
"I just want to make a comment about the obvious issue and that is the failure of Congress to act yesterday. Its just not acceptable. […] This is just a not acceptable situation. I’m not saying this is the perfect answer. If I were dictator, which I always aspire to be, I would write it a little bit differently."
McCain on announcing you intend to attack another country:
21.
Flip:During a brief stop at a sandwich shoppe in Philadelphia, one voter was able to do what no reporter has been able to do so far on the campaign trail... ask Governor Palin an unscripted question:
[A]pproached by a man wearing a Temple University t-shirt, who later identified himself as Michael Rovito, Palin was asked:
“How about the Pakistan situation? What’s your thoughts about that.”
“In Pakistan?” Palin responded.
“What’s going on over there, like Waziristian?”
“It’s working with Zardari to make sure that we’re all working together to stop the guys from coming in over the border,” Palin said. “And we’ll go from there.”
“Waziristan is blowing up,” Rovito replied.
“Yeah, it is,” Palin said. “And the economy there is blowing up, too.”
“So we do cross-border, like from Afghanistan to Pakistan, you think?” Rovito asked.
“If that’s what we have to do stop the terrorists from coming any further in, absolutely, we should,” Palin said.
During the first Presidential debate, Senator McCain criticized Senator Obama for "announcing" that "if we had actionable intelligence on the whereabouts of bin Laden inside Pakistan, and the Pakistani government refused to act", he would be willing to send troops into Pakistan to get him. McCain criticized Obama, saying that you don't reveal to the enemy what you are and are not willing to do militarily.
Flop: Later, in a joint interview, CBS's Katie Couric asked Governor Palin about her comment and how it appeared she had done exactly what Senator McCain had vocally criticized Senator Obama for doing. McCain dismissed the exchange as "gotcha journalism", though the man asking the question was not a reporter and did not ask a question that appeared to be anything other than what it was: a question about her position on an issue.
Back-flop: However, in the days... even hours... after 9/11, Senator McCain was already publicly announcing his support for the invasion of Iraq:
PAULA ZAHN: And as you know, Senator, the U.S. and Great Britain notified the U.N. Security Council yesterday that they reserve the right to strike against other countries in this campaign. What countries are we looking at?
McCAIN: Well, I think very obviously Iraq is the first country, but there are others — Syria, Iran, the Sudan, who have continued to harbor terrorist organizations and actually assist them.
McCain on using the term "Victory" when describing Iraq:
.20
Gaffe: Senator McCain criticized Senator Obama's performance at the September 28th Presidential Debate, noting that Senator Obama never once used the word "victory" in describing Iraq:
"By the way, on Friday night, did you ever hear the word victory from Senator Obama?"
CROWD: No!
McCAIN: My friends, if we continue this surge under this great general, we will come home – and our troops will come home – with victory and honor. And not in defeat.
However, the "great general" McCain is referring to above, General Petraeus, has explicitly suggested not using such language to refer to the war. “This is not the sort of struggle where you take a hill, plant the flag and go home to a victory parade… it’s not war with a simple slogan,” Petraeus said. He added that he doesn’t think he’ll ever use the word, citing the “need for real restraint” in public pronouncements.
Flip: Senator McCain has spent a great deal of time during his campaign in constant criticism of Senator Obama's plan to subsidize tax cuts for the Middle Class by rolling back the Bush Tax Cuts on the wealthiest Americans.
Flop: During the first Presidential debate on September 28th, Senator McCain admitted that his healthcare plan might benefit many low-income Americans at the expense of those with the most extravagant health care plans:
"Actually, my position is that it will be, it will give people actually more money to go out and purchase tax - health insurance on their own and only those with the Cadillac gold-plated health insurance policies today are the ones who might suffer from it."
Flip: On September 24th, when announcing he would be "suspending his campaign" to concentrate of the Wall Street financial crisis, Senator McCain also called for "bipartisanship":
"“We must meet as Americans, not as Democrats or Republicans, and we must meet until this crisis is resolved."
Flop: Upon returning to Washington, McCain contacted and spoke exclusively to Republicans:
The New York Times reports that McCain aides “released a list of people they said Mr. McCain had called from his campaign headquarters on Saturday.” Among them were:
President Bush
Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
Sen. Judd Gregg (R-NH)
Sen. Jon Kyl (R-AZ)
House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH)
House Minority Whip Roy Blunt (R-MO)
The list included “nine House Republicans.” No Democrats were listed. Senator McCain's only interaction with Democrats was during the bipartisan meeting at the White House on Thursday. During that meeting, McCain “played a shockingly passive role,” sitting silently for 40 minutes, and refusing to discuss his position on the bailout.
Flip: On September 24th, Senator McCain announced that, so serious was the banking crisis, that he was suspending his campaign and flying back to Washington to concentrate on the crisis.
Flop: Three days later on September 27th, Senator McCain failed to even show up for bailout negotiations on Capitol Hill, choosing instead to stay in his Arlington apartment and (according to campaign staffer Mark Salter) "he can do what he needs to do by phone."
The next day on "Fox News Sunday", McCain campaign surrogate Lindsey Graham criticized Senator Obama for refusing to returning to Washington, claiming that "You can’t phone something like this in."
Gaffe: During a town hall in Scranton, PA on Monday, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) declared that “there’s only one ethnic joke that can be told in American politics and that’s Irish jokes.” McCain then preceded to tell a joke about drunk Irish twins.
Politico’s Ben Smith reported that Seamus Boyle, the president of the Ancient Order of Hibernian's (an Irish-Catholic organization), said the joke "was really an insult to a whole nationality to be stereotyped as drunks."
Editor's note: Senator McCain might believe that it is okay to tell jokes about an entire ethnic group so long as you are a member of said group (eg: blacks telling blacks jokes or Polish people telling Polish jokes), but Senator McCain seems unaware that "McCain" is a Scottish name, not Irish (Scottish names typically begin with "Mc" or "Mac" where Irish names commonly begin with "O'" as in "O'Brien"). I do not know of Senator McCain's paternal lineage, but it is a fair bet most others do not as well.
McCain on staying in Washington until Wall Street crisis is resolved:
15.
Flip: In a move that was roundly criticized as a "political stunt", Senator McCain vowed to "suspend his campaign" and fly back to Washington until the financial crisis on Wall Street was resolved. Senator McCain also urged his opponent, Senator Obama to do the same. McCain also threatened to possibly not show up for the first scheduled Presidential Debate later that same week if the banking crisis were not resolved by then.
Flop: Despite no resolution in Washington, Senator McCain announced ten hours before the debate that he would indeed be attending, flying down to Mississippi for the debate and then flying straight back to D.C. to continue working on the banking crisis.
McCain on suspending his campaign (and dissing David Letterman):
14.
Deception: On September 24th, Senator McCain announced that he would be flying back to Washington "immediately" to concentrate on the current financial crisis on Wall Street. Though scheduled to appear on CBS's "The Late Show with David Letterman" later that day,
the McCain campaign called host David Letterman to cancel at the last minute, informing him that the Senator was "getting on a plane immediately to race back to Washington." Stuck without a guest, the visibly annoyed Letterman chided McCain throughout his monologue, saying that McCain could simply of sent Governor Palin in his place, and questioned the "real" reason for Senator McCain's sudden attention to his duties in Washington.
Flash forward 15 minutes later when someone informs Letterman that... not only was McCain NOT currently rushing back to Washington, but was in fact 5 blocks away (from 52nd street to 57th street) preparing for an interview with CBS Evening News anchor Katie Couric.
Editor's note: Also, as I point out on "Mugsy's Rap Sheet", the McCain interview with Couric was in addition to segments of Couric's interview with Governor Palin running every night that week. So with clips of the Palin interview running each night, followed by clips of the Senator McCain interview, with McCain campaign ads continuing to run on network TV and McCain campaign surrogates taking to the airwaves daily to attack Senator Obama (much of it, criticizing his refusal to suspend his own campaign as well as the Friday Presidential Debate), only to return to the campaign in time for the Friday Night debate later that same week, at what point did Senator McCain actually suspend his campaign? (which brings us to #15 above.)
"Sen. John McCain said that if he were president, he would fire SEC Chairman Chris Cox for his “betrayal of trust” leading up to this week’s financial market crisis."
Problem is, the Securities and Exchange Commission, which regulates the trading of stocks & bonds, is an independent agency outside the jurisdiction of the White House. While the President "nominates", and the Senate approves, the SEC chairman, the President does not have the power to fire him/her.
(EDITOR'S NOTE: If Senator McCain is looking for someone to "fire" for the current fiscal crisis, he should consider starting with his financial advisor Phil "nation of whiners" Gramm, who pushed through the deregulation that made the current crisis possible, and who... despite claims otherwise... is still advising the McCain campaign.)
UPDATE: Realizing that the President does not have the power to "fire" the Chairman of the SEC, the next day, Senator McCain openly called for the Chairman of the FEC (which would be the Federal Election Commission) to resign.
Gaffe(?): The Spanish press is buzzing after U.S. presidential candidate John McCain failed to correctly identify Prime Minister Zapatero of Spain. According to the reporter that spoke with Senator McCain:
"Tuve la sensacion de que McCain no sabia de quien le estaba hablando."
(translation: "I had the feeling that McCain didn't know what he was talking about.")
According to one Spanish speaking TPM reader, "He gets confused in the interview, apparently thinking Zapatero is someone from Latin America who is an enemy of the United States and manages to create a minor international incident."
This is an odd one, making headlines in Spain but, likely due to the language barrier, seems slow in catching on here in the U.S.. The McCain/Palin ticket's credibility on "Foreign policy experience" vs. the Obama/Biden ticket seems to be evaporating faster than boiled alcohol.
(Special thanks to reader Bill Newsome for the link.)
UPDATE: ThinkProgress has revealed that the McCain campaign is claiming the "gaffe" was in fact intentional:
"McCain’s top foreign policy adviser Randy Scheunemann said McCain was not confused — he was simply articulating his policy of refusing to commit to a White House meeting with Zapatero."
Zapatero, the newly re-elected Prime Minister of Spain and former supporter of President Bush's "War on TerrorTM", won reelection by pulling all Spanish troops out of Iraq back in 2004. The Bush Administration... and now it seems McCain... is expressing their displeasure with the move by "intentionally" (???) pretending not to know who Zapatero is (or, it may just be a cover story concocted by the McCain campaign to cover for his gaffe. Either way, these games are not befitting a Presidential candidate.)
Flip: During an appearance on NBC's "Today Show" on September 16th, Senator McCain opposed the idea of a bailout of "AIG" when asked by host Matt Lauer "what should the government do [about AIG]?"
"No, I do not believe that the American taxpayer should be on the hook for AIG and I’m glad that the Secretary Paulson has apparently taken the same line."
Flop: The next day, on ABC's "Good Morning America", after-the-fact, Senator McCain supported the $85B bailout of AIG, responding this way when asked about it:
"I didn’t want to do that. And I don’t think anybody I know wanted to do that. But there are literally millions of people whose retirement, whose investment, whose insurance were at risk here. They were going to have their lives destroyed because of the greed and excess and corruption."
Recognizing the need for the bailout "after the fact" is one thing. But under a "President McCain", the bailout he recognized as necessary 24 hours later might never of taken place.
During a speech in Tampa today, John McCain demonstrated again that the economy is not something he understands as well as he should. He twice incorrectly referred to the “SPIC,” when intending to refer to the SIPC (the Securities Investor Protection Corporation) — a corporation that “return[s] customers’ cash, stock and other securities” if a brokerage goes bankrupt.
Additionally, McCain called the “SPIC” a regulatory agency. In fact, as Andrew Jakabovics explains, SIPC’s own website states that it is “neither a government agency nor a regulatory authority.”
(EDITOR'S NOTE: Had Senator McCain had simply of erred on the order of the letters in SIPC, I likely would of let this "gaffe" slide, but misidentifying it as "a government regulatory authority" is all the more significant when his running mate ALSO misidentified non-government entities, Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac, as having “gotten too big and too expensive to the taxpayers.” the week before, underscoring their lack of understanding of the economy in these precarious financial times.
While this is not the first time Senator McCain has committed four significant gaffes in a 24-hour period (See July #18), the rate at which these "mistakes" are occurring should be of SERIOUS concern to ALL voters.)
Flip: On a number of occasions, Senator McCain has repeated the Party line that he "strongly opposes" government regulation of free-market enterprises. From the WSJ:
With regard to the current economic crisis, the McCain campaign is now arguing for “strong regulatory oversight of Wall Street.” McCain, however, has long held that he is “fundamentally a deregulator.” As he told the Wall Street Journal in March:
I’m always for less regulation. But I am aware of the view that there is a need for government oversight. … But I am a fundamentally a deregulator. I’d like to see a lot of the unnecessary government regulations eliminated.
Flop: On NBC’s Today Show, McCain told Matt Lauer:
"Of course I don’t like excessive and unnecessary regu — uh, government regulation."
Less than an hour later on CBS's Early Show, McCain tells host Harry Smith:
"Do I believe in excess government regulation? Yes. But this patchwork quilt of regulating bodies was designed for the 1930s when they were invented."
Not only is this McCain's fastest flip-flop yet, it has been less that 24 hours since his LAST record-setting flip-flop noted in #8 below.
UPDATE: Jed Lewison ("The Jed Report") has compiled a great little video for The Huffington Post on "the Party of Deregulation":
UPDATE: On September 15th, Senator Obama used the old colloquialism, "lipstick on a pig", to describe the 5-term senator's suggestion that he (McCain) was the best candidate to bring about "real change in Washington". The McCain campaign quickly responded, claiming that Obama's use of the term "lipstick on a pig" was a veiled reference to running mate Palin's use of the word "lipstick" to distinguish herself from a "pitbull", as noted in her Convention speech.
When asked if he truly believed that Senator Obama was referring to Governor Palin when he made his comment, one alert reader made the following observation:
When McCain was asked, "Did [Obama] call her a pig?" he said, "No...but I know that he chooses his words carefully, and it was the wrong thing to say."
McCain appears to be committing a flip-flop in mid-sentence, saying that he did not believe Senator Obama was calling Palin "a pig", yet indicating that in "choosing his words carefully", he was in fact deliberately making that very suggestion.
McCain on the state of the economy (in the space of a couple of hours):
8.
Flip: During a rally in Jacksonville, FL on September 15th, Senator McCain adamantly reasserted that, despite the failure of yet another major financial institution, Lehman Brothers, precipitating a 500+ point plunge in the DOW, that "the fundamentals of our economy are strong."
Flop: In a second speech in nearby Orlando, FL just hours later, Senator McCain had this to say about the state of our economy:
"I know Americans are hurting, and the fundamentals of our economy are at risk. They're at risk. [...] Our economy is at risk today."
This HAS to be the fastest flip-flop in history.
(Update: ThinkProgress has documented 18 times so far this year that Senator McCain has insisted that "the fundamentals of our economy are strong.")
Deception: On at least 5 occasions, Senator McCain has introduced his running mate, Alaska Governor Sarah Palin, as having "opposed the (infamous) Bridge to Nowhere" (including Palin herself, the McCain campaign has repeated the "opposed the B2N" myth 35 times).
Today, Senator McCain personally defended his running mate on the B2N myth rather than concede overwhelming evidence that Palin in fact supported and even campaigned for the bridge in her 2006 gubernatorial bid, only pulling the plug on the project once it had become a symbol of wasteful spending across the nation (and keeping the majority of the funds anyway), the McCain campaign has decided that her eventual "awakening" to the fact such a project was deemed extraordinarily wasteful "after the fact" is sufficient grounds to defend their assertion she is a champion against wasteful spending in the mold of McCain himself: (FactCheck.org has a well documented examination of all the earmarks that Senator McCain criticized, but in fact didn't root out himself and in most occasions, failed to oppose.)
(EDITORS NOTE: Back on #2, I noted that McCain himself had yet to concede Palin in fact pursued the B2N. It appears now that the McCain campaign has no intention of conceding the obvious. As such, I will not count each additional defense of this myth as an additional "Deception".)
Deception: During his second appearance on ABC's "The View", Senator McCain was asked (and responded to) the following observation:
WALTERS: What is she going to reform specifically, Senator?
McCAIN: Well, first of all, earmark spending, which she vetoed a half a billion dollars worth in the state of Alaska.
WALTERS: She also took some earmarks there.
BEHAR: A lot.
McCAIN: No, not as governor she didn’t, she vetoed…
WALTERS: As Mayor.
McCAIN: Well, look, the fact is that she was a reform governor.
Via ThinkProgress:
– Though Palin did reduce Alaska’s earmark requests, “in her two years in office, Alaska has requested nearly $750 million in special federal spending, by far the largest per-capita request in the nation.”
Additionally, McCain economic advisor Carly Fiorina appeared on ABC's "This Week", where she repeated the exact same false defense of Palin:
FIORINA: Sarah Palin as governor stood up and said, I know earmarks are corrupting. We must ask for less of them–
McCain on how being Mayor or Governor is insufficient preparation to be President:
5.
Gaffe: During the Republican Primary Debate hosted by Fox News on October 21, 2007, Senator McCain took a not-so-subtle swipe at the experience of two of his chief opponents: Rudy Giuliani and Mitt Romney:
"I have had a strong and a long relationship on national security, I've been involved in every national crisis that this nation has faced since Beirut, I understand the issues, I understand and appreciate the enormity of the challenge we face from radical Islamic extremism.
I am prepared. I am prepared. I need no on-the-job training.
I wasn't a mayor for a short period of time. I wasn't a governor for a short period of time. For 20-some years, including leading the largest squadron in the United States Navy, I led. I didn't manage for profit, I led for patriotism."
So if Senator McCain is to be taken at his word, being "a mayor or governor for a short period of time" is inadequate training to be President of the United States.
Enter Sarah Palin.
Gaffe: On September 8th, Senator McCain attacked Senator Obama on military spending, referring to a YouTube video where Senator Obama said, “I will cut investments in unproven missile defense systems. I will not weaponize space. I will slow our development of future combat systems."
McCain was apparently unaware that back in July, his own campaign’s senior economic adviser submitted a “plan to balance the federal budget by 2013" that noted:
"Balance the budget requires slowing outlay growth to 2.4 percent. The roughly $470 billion dollars (by 2013) in slower spending growth come from reduced deployments abroad ($150 billion; consistent with success in Iraq/Afghanistan that permits deployments to be cut by half — hopefully more), slower discretionary spending in non-defense and Pentagon procurements ($160 billion; there are lots of procurements — airborne laser, Globemaster, Future Combat System — that should be ended and the entire Pentagon budget should be scrubbed)."
So while Senator McCain is criticizing Senator Obama, saying he would put the country at risk by "slowing" the development of FCS, McCain's own economic advisor has promised McCain would "end" the program and the entire Pentagon budget would be "scrubbed".
Flip: In a March 25th speech in Santa Ana, CA, Senator McCain criticized talk of a proposed plan for the Federal Government to bail out the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac home mortgage lending institutions, stating:
"It's not the duty of government to bail out and reward those who act irresponsibly, whether it be big banks or small borrowers."
Flop: On September 7th, following the announcement that the Federal Government would indeed be bailing out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to the tune of $14 Billion dollars, the McCain Campaign released the following statement:
"John McCain supports the steps needed to keep the financial troubles at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac from further squeezing American families..."
Back-Flip: Before he was against bailing out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Senator McCain was for the $30 Billion dollar Federal bailout of investment-bank Bear-Stearns:
Asked whether the Fed went too far in helping Bear Stearns, McCain said: "It's a close call, but I don't think so."He said he doesn't support federal bailouts unless there otherwise would be catastrophic effects on the financial marketplace. He said there were indications a Bear Stearns failure would have rippled across the economy.
Combined, Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac are responsible for nearly HALF the home mortgages in the United States, a $12 Trillion dollar market.
Ibid
9/7/08
McCain on Sarah Palin's fiscal irresponsibility:
2.
Flip: On August 29th, Senator John McCain chose Alaska Governor Sarah Palin to be his Vice Presidential running mate, saying of her record:
"I found someone with an outstanding record of standing up to special interests [...] someone who has stopped government from wasting taxpayer money on things they don't want or need and put it back to work for the people."
Flop: In his fight against earmarks & wasteful spending, McCain criticized the Mayor of Wasilla, Alaska, Sarah Palin, for wasteful spending of Federal Funds:
Three times in recent years, McCain's catalogs of "objectionable" spending have included earmarks for this small Alaska town, requested by its mayor at the time -- Sarah Palin.
[...]
In 2001, McCain's list of spending that had been approved without the normal budget scrutiny included a $500,000 earmark for a public transportation project in Wasilla. The Arizona senator targeted $1 million in a 2002 spending bill for an emergency communications center in town -- one that local law enforcement has said is redundant and creates confusion.
McCain also criticized $450,000 set aside for an agricultural processing facility in Wasilla that was requested during Palin's tenure as mayor and cleared Congress soon after she left office in 2002. The funding was provided to help direct locally grown produce to schools, prisons and other government institutions, according to Taxpayers for Common Sense, a nonpartisan watchdog group.
Wasilla received $11.9 million in earmarks from 2000 to 2003. The results of this spending are very apparent today. (The town also benefited from $15 million in federal funds to promote regional rail transportation.)
In addition, consider that, thanks to a tax Palin imposed upon oil companies operating in Alaska, Alaskan residents already receive $1,200 each annually in compensation... money that the oil companies make up by charging higher prices at the pump.
Alaska costs American taxpayers tens of millions of dollars each year.
(EDITORS NOTE: I am still waiting on Senator McCain to respond to allegations that his VP pick was in fact a key supporter of the "Bridge to Nowhere", only opposing it once it became a very public example of wasteful spending. When he does, you can be sure it will appear here.)
Flip: In a June 4, 2000 interview, Presidential candidate John McCain had some choice words for the man who lead a smear campaign against him that suggested his adopted Bengali daughter, Bridget, was his "illegitimate love child" in a telephone push poll:
Dadmag: During your campaign for the Republican Presidential nomination Bridget became something of an issue in South Carolina didn't she?
McCain: Yeah. There were some pretty vile and hurtful things said during the South Carolina primary. It's a really nasty side of politics. We tried to ignore it and I think we shielded her from it. It's just unfortunate that that sort of thing still exists As you know she's Bengali, and very dark skinned. A lot of phone calls were made by people who said we should be very ashamed about her, about the color of her skin. Thousands and thousands of calls from people to voters saying "You know the McCain's have a black baby" I believe that there is a special place in hell for people like those."
Flop: ABC News reports: "McCain Hires GOP Operative Who Helped Smear Him in South Carolina in 2000":
"Former officials of Sen. John McCain’s 2000 campaign expressed shock and disbelief Monday to learn than the GOP presidential nominee had hired South Carolina political consultant Tucker Eskew.
Eskew, along with Warren Tompkins and Neal Rhodes, were key members of then-Gov. George W. Bush’s South Carolina team during the 2000 primaries. McCain and his team long held Bush, Tompkins, Rhodes and Eskew responsible for the various smears against McCain and his family in the Palmetto state during that contentious contest. […]
Asked if the McCain campaign would have a comment about hiring one of the South Carolina strategists the senator and his 2000 campaign team once held responsible for smears against him, McCain 2008 spokesman Brian Rogers emailed, “No."
Flip: In numerousads and interviews, Senator McCain has frequently pushed the "experience" argument to argue that Senator Obama is not qualified to be President of the United States.
Flop: In response to mounting questions regarding his choice of Sarah Palin, a first-term governor of Alaska whose experience includes "former beauty queen", "TV sports caster" for the local news, and (I'm not kidding) "member of the PTA", was qualified "from day one" to step in as President should something happen to the 72 year old cancer survivor, Senator McCain stressed Palin's "judgment" over her "lack of experience":
Deception: On numerousoccasions now, the newly appointed VP pick, Alaska Governor Sarah Palin has been credited with standing up to her own party by opposing Senator Ted Steven's "Bridge to Nowhere":
On ABC’s This Week, Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) similarly argued that Palin is a reformer because she supposedly said, “I’m not going to build a Bridge to Nowhere.” This Week host George Stephanopoulos pointed out that Graham’s claim is false:
GRAHAM: To go in her state and say ‘I’m not going to build a bridge to nowhere’ — a $400 - $400 million appropriation that was passed by brute force in the Congress by two senior members of the congressional delegation, very powerful figures in Washington. And for her to say, ‘We’re not going to do this because its not necessary and its wasteful,’ to take on your own Republican party –
STEPHANOPOULOS: But Senator, she turned against that, only she campaigned for it in her 2006 race, and turned against it in 2007 only after it became a national joke."
Flop: But links abound of her support for such a tax:
"Over the opposition of oil companies, Republican Gov. Sarah Palin and Alaska's Legislature last year approved a major increase in taxes on the oil industry — a step that has generated stunning new wealth for the state as oil prices soared."
Gaffe: Let's just label this one a "gaffe" and not "deception", because I have no doubt the good Senator from Arizona truly believes he hasn't flip-flopped on anything.
From ThinkProgress:
McCain dismisses any claims that he’s changed positions, telling the AP “in all due respect” that his former colleagues are “drinking the Kool-Aid“:
“In all due respect to my colleagues,” he says, “They’re drinking the Kool-Aid that somehow I have changed positions on the issues. All I can say is that we all grow. We all grow wiser. And we all refine our positions.”
(Editor's note: While Senator McCain has been heavy on "gaffes" and outright "deception" lately, he has already racked up eight "flip-flops" just this month alone, which is barely three weeks old. While our listing is incomplete, of the 69 anomalies we have documented thus far, 41 are "flip-flops" (not counting double flips & back-flips. In all due fairness to the Senator, he has given himself "wiggle-room" on just about every FF, from "timetables in Iraq" to "allowing the use of torture". In that regard, he is far more of a "lying gaffe machine" than he is in giving "nuanced" positions that could be called "flip-flops").
McCain on urging Rumsfeld for more troops in Iraq:
14.
Deception: (via ThinkProgress) Throughout his campaign, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) has disguised his support for a failed strategy in Iraq by regularly railing against Donald Rumsfeld. A lengthy Washington Times article today highlighting McCain’s advocacy for more troops (calling it a “David against Goliath” battle) reveals that McCain’s push for more troops may have been more tepid than he portrays.
In an August 2003 meeting with Rumsfeld, McCain “made a very passionate case that we need to look at adding more troops,” according to Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC). But in a note from Rumsfeld just after meeting, McCain reportedly told Rumsfeld, “the answer may not be more troops in Iraq“:
An aide to the secretary said Mr. McCain’s account is incorrect. “In November 2003, Secretary Rumsfeld and Senator McCain had one of a number of conversations that ended with the two in agreement on the need to win in Iraq,” Keith Urbahn said. “Senator McCain may prefer to characterize their meeting as a Showdown at the OK Corral, but that’s not straight talk. It’s a fairy tale.”
Gaffe: Following a video produced by Robert Greenwald's Brave New Films that points out that while Senator McCain has been talking tough on "bailing out" "irresponsible" home buyers seeking protection from foreclosure, he himself owns as many as ten homes across the country, a reporter from Politico asked Senator McCain exactly how many homes he indeed owns:
McCain: "I think — I'll have my staff get to you," McCain told Politico in Las Cruces, N.M. "It's condominiums where — I'll have them get to you."
(Editor's note: In another interview, Senator McCain was asked to define "rich", which he put at "$5million dollars". I have chosen not to include this statement as a gaffe because it is unclear if he believed $5million is when you "start" to define "rich" or if that's just a number he pulled out of the air.)
ThinkProgress: Unfortunately, these reporters are ignoring an obvious and glaring reality that McCain is running a campaign of the rich, by the rich, and for the rich. He recently defined rich as earning $5 million or more and doesn’t know how many houses he owns, and at the same time, McCain is proposing a tax policy that primarilybenefits the rich. In fact, under his proposal, McCain himself would receive a $300,000 tax cut, while middle class Americans would receive only a few hundred.
Moreover, while ordinary Americans are struggling to keep the one house they own, McCain has a record of denying assistance to homeowners, having voted against mortgage protections and other steps to help consumers fight unfair credit terms.
"One night after being mistreated as a POW, a guard loosened the ropes binding me, easing my pain. On Christmas, that same guard approached me. Without saying a word, he drew a cross in the sand. We stood wordlessly looking at the cross remembering the true light of Christmas..."
It has been discovered that McCain's "cross in the sand" story bears a striking resemblance to a story told about the recently deceased Alexander Solzhenitsyn about his time in a Soviet gulag:
"(...) Leaving his shovel on the ground, he slowly walked to a crude bench and sat down. He knew that at any moment a guard would order him to stand up, and when he failed to respond, the guard would beat him to death, probably with his own shovel. He had seen it happen to other prisoners.
As he waited, head down, he felt a presence. Slowly he looked up and saw a skinny old prisoner squat down beside him. The man said nothing. Instead, he used a stick to trace in the dirt the sign of the Cross. The man then got back up and returned to his work.
As Solzhenitsyn stared at the Cross drawn in the dirt his entire perspective changed. (...)"
(Editor's note: I find it odd that no one has ever questioned Sen. McCain about why a North Vietnamese guard, coming from a non-Christian country, would be "drawing crosses in the sand and reflecting on the true meaning of Xmas with a POW". Another note, President Ronald Reagan, a B-movie actor during WWII, was known on several occasions to confuse things that happened to him in real life with things he did in the movies. Not long after, he was diagnosed with Alzheimers.See #6 below to see why this is becoming a serious trend.)
Deception: Senator McCain, during his appearance with Pastor Rick Warren for his first joint appearance with Senator Obama, repeated a story he has told frequently to illustrate "just how evil" the "Islamo-fascists" we're fighting in Iraq are:
"Not long ago in Baghdad, Al Qaeda took two young women who were mentally disabled and put suicide vests on them, sent them into a marketplace, and by remote control, detonated those suicide vests," McCain told Rick Warren. "If that isn't evil, you have to tell me what is."
Problem is, the story is an urban legend that, despite having been debunked, the Senator continues to repeat.
Flip: Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) currently holds the title of most absent U.S. senator, missing over 60 percent of votes this session. In an interview with Walter Isaacson at the Aspen Institute yesterday [Aug 14], McCain claimed he has not “missed any crucial vote” on energy legislation:
McCAIN: "I have a long record of that support of alternate energy. … I’ve always been for all of those and I have not missed any crucial vote. But my citizens in Arizona know that when I’m running for the President of the United States I have to be out campaigning."
Flop: Actually, Senator McCain is zero-for-8 in voting on crucial renewable energy legislation this past year, allowing a bill to extend energy tax credits to wind & solar power industries to be defeated in Congress. Once, he wouldn't even leave his office while present at the Senate to cast his vote.
McCain on the Supreme Court's 2007 Gitmo Detainee ruling:
9.
Flip: During a question-and-answer session with Walter Isaacson today [8/14], Sen. John McCain said Guantanamo Bay is “one of the nicest places in the world to live in.” Later in the interview, McCain was asked about the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Boumediene v. Bush declaring that Gitmo detainees have a right to challenge their detention in civilian court. McCain had previously derided that decision as “one of the worst decisions in the history of this country.”
Flop: The exchange with Senator McCain went thusly:
ISAACSON: "But you called that the worst decision in history?"
McCAIN: "No I didn’t. No, no– Sometimes I’m given to a little hyperbole."
(Click link for video.)
Editor's note: McCain appears to flip-flop once again in the same video on the subject of whether or not the U.S. should be torturing prisoners. Despite having defended and then voting for a provision to allow the CIA to continue torturing prisoners at their discretion (in spite of his prior objections to the practice), McCain then goes on to relates an anecdote of how a reformed al Qaeda operative now working for the U.S. told him how the use of torture by the Americans was used as a propaganda tool to motivate radicals and assist al Qaeda in recruiting.
McCain on using the Georgia conflict for political gain:
8.
Flip: CBS News:
"John McCain told reporters today [Aug 13] that he does not want the hostile attacks of Russia on its neighboring country Georgia to be politicized in this campaign, despite the fact that his members of his campaign have been doing so this week.
Asked about criticisms by Barack Obama's campaign saying he was being “belligerent and aggressive” toward Russia, McCain replied, “This isn't a time for partisanship and sniping between campaigns. This is about hundreds if not thousands of innocent people whose lives are being taken or they are being rendered homeless, wounded. This is not time for that to start with."
Flop: But just yesterday [Aug 12], both McCain supporter Sen. Joe Lieberman, I-Conn., and McCain’s foreign policy advisor Randy Scheunemann did exactly that.
Scheunemann told reporters, “I think the first major speech (McCain) gave expressing concerns about Russian policies in former Warsaw Pact or former Soviet Pact was in 1993. I don’t know when the first statement Senator Obama might have given about Russia when he started issuing statements on Russia. So there’s a depth of knowledge, a breadth of knowledge and an extent of historical experience that doesn’t compare between the two on Russian policy.”
“You can’t compare a 15-year historical record with three or four statements over the course of fifteen months,” he added.
Yesterday in Teaneck, N.J., Lieberman criticized Obama to a group of fundraisers, saying, “If you read the statements from the beginning, Senator McCain and Senator Obama, one had kind of moral neutrality to it, that comes I think from inexperience. The other, Senator McCain, was strong and clear and principled and put America where America always wants to be.”
When reporters pointed out Lieberman’s statement to McCain, who was standing next to Lieberman during today's press conference, McCain gave a response that left some confused.
“Well, let me respond by, by just saying that, I think that whatever we think at the moment, that we can all reserve that for a future time. And I think judgments will be made about how we handled that situation, how we approached the situation in Iraq, and how much experience and knowledge and background means in selecting the American people’s decision as to who should be the next commander in chief. And so all I can say is there will be plenty of time for that.”
Lieberman remained silent during the press conference.
In an August 17, 2007 radio interview, Senator McCain pledged he "would do everything I can to make the Bush tax cuts permanent."
During a town hall speech in Denver (7/7/08), Senator McCain stated, "The choice in this election is stark and simple. Senator Obama will raise your taxes. I won't,"
In an interview on ABC's "This Week", Senator McCain said that "Everything is on the table" with regards to raising taxes.
Forced to respond to outraged Conservatives over his comments on ABC, Senator McCain again pledged, "I want to look you in the eye... I will. Not. Raise your taxes, nor support a tax increase."
Flop(?): On August 6, Senator McCain tapped former U.S. Comptroller David H. Walker to help balance the federal budget, calling the deficit hawk someone who could help convey "the truth" to the public.
However, in a January 11, 2007 budget hearing before Congress, Walker testified:
"The picture I will lay out for you today is not a pretty one and it’s getting worse with the passage of time. [...] Continuing on our current fiscal path would gradually erode, if not suddenly damage, our economy, our standard of living, and ultimately even our domestic tranquility and our national security. [...] balancing the budget in [sic] 2040 could require actions as large as cutting total federal spending by 60 percent or raising federal taxes to 2 times today’s level."
So the "truth telling" deficit hawk McCain says he would appoint to balance the Federal Budget says that the only way to do so within the next 32 years while continuing Bush's economic policies is either to slash federal spending by more than half OR double the current tax rate.
Ibid
8/6/08
McCain on energy conservation via small changes:
6.
Flip: Following a comment by Senator Obama that "proper tire inflation" could save as much energy as the GOP’s coastal drilling policy, McCain responded the next day:
McCain: "Yesterday, he [Obama] suggested we put air in our tires to save on gas. My friends, let’s do that. But do you think that’s enough to break our dependence on Middle Eastern oil? I don’t think so."
Of course, Obama never claimed "proper tire inflation alone" would end our dependence on foreign oil. Note that "electronic tire pressure monitoring" is now standard equipment on most luxury cars, underscoring the importance of proper tire inflation with regards to fuel efficiency, performance and safety.
Flop: Just last April, Senator McCain, while commenting on the same subject of "dependency on foreign oil", McCain suggested:
"We can do that [decrease our dependence] as a nation. We can turned out [sic] the lights five minutes earlier. We don't have to drive the extra block."
(Editors Note: It is almost surreal that Senator McCain seems to be making a habit of criticizing his opponent for comments on subjects McCain himself injected into the debate just weeks earlier. Should the issue of "looming Alzheimer's" now be injected into the debate?)
McCain volunteers wife for Topless beauty contest:
5.
Gaffe: "Knowingly" or "unknowingly", no one can say for sure, but during a campaign appearance in Sturgis, S.D., Senator McCain proffered his wife as a potential contestant in their "Miss Buffalo Chip" beauty contest, in which many contestants... at their own discretion... often choose to compete in "topless", and in some cases, even "bottomless".
Though likely an innocent gaffe, it would not merit mention here had it not been for McCain's prior lapses in judgment (documented in prior months) when it comes to women and inappropriate sexual situations:
a) Last June, McCain had to abruptly reschedule a fundraiser at the home of Texas telecom millionaire Clayton Williams, who lost the 1990 Texas Governors race after comparing rape to "the weather".
b) Also in June, McCain responded to questions of why he refused to meet with Nevada Governor Jim Gibbons with a flubbed joke about wife-beating.
c) According to aides & reporters present at the time, in 1992, a suddenly enraged Senator McCain called his wife Cindy a "c*nt" on the Senator floor.
It is only because of these repeated instances of Senator McCain's insensitivity towards women and sexual abuse that we include this gaffe here.
Flip: A new campaign ad with strong apocalyptic religious overtones entitled "The One" suggests that Senator Obama believes himself to be "The Savior" of America.
Flop: Once again, the McCain campaign is caught scrubbing their website for any reference to Senator McCain calling himself "the one" ("the one who will...") Again, diligent bloggers rescued the comments before they disappeared down "the Memory Hole".
McCain on Accusing Obama of "playing the Race Card":
3.
Deception: The McCain campaign was quick to jump on comments by Senator Obama at a July 31st campaign rally:
OBAMA: "[They say:] You know, 'He's not patriotic enough. He's got a funny name.' You know, 'He doesn't look like all those other presidents on those dollar bills.'"
By saying "he doesn't look like all those other presidents on those dollar bills", the McCain campaign suggested Obama was "playing the race card", indirectly accusing the McCain campaign of racism. When in fact, it was the McCain campaign who, in a TV ad last June, showed images of Obama replacing every president on Mt. Rushmore, and replacing the image of Ben Franklin on the $100 bill with the face of Obama. It was this ad that Senator Obama was responding to. (see video at link)
Flip: The McCain campaign released an attack ad entitled "Celebrity", in which Senator Obama was compared to the likes of "Britney Spears" and "Paris Hilton" (notorious "vacuous blondes") claiming that Barack Obama is merely a celebrity with no real accomplishments.
Flop: While the McCain campaign was defending their "Celebrity" ad, they were simultaneously scrubbing their own website for any reference of Senator McCain as a "celebrity". Fortunately, alert bloggers captured and preserved the references before they disappeared down "the Memory Hole".
(Editor's Note: Many others have noted that Senator McCain owes his entire career to his "celebrity" as a former POW. McCain was on the first-ever edition of "Jeopardy!" back in 1964, when he screwed up a Final Jeopardy question about Heathcliff from the novel "Wuthering Heights." He later made a guest appearance on the current "Jeopardy!" with Alex Trebec to introduce a Final Jeopardy question. He has appeared on "The Tonight Show with Jay Leno" 10 times, "Late Night with David Letterman" 8 times, Comedy Central's "Daily Show" 12 times, two guest appearances on "Saturday Night Live", and a cameo in the movie "Wedding Crashers".)
Flip: When answering questions following a speech he gave in Panama City, FL, Senator McCain answered a question regarding his support for African-Americans by stating:
"...I'm proud of that record... from fighting for the recognition of Doctor Martin Luther King's birthday in my state, to sponsoring specific legislation that would prevent discrimination..."
Flop: Senator McCain appears to have forgotten that he fought against making Dr. King's birthday a Federal holiday, not once but three times (follow link for details).
(Editor's Note: It was only this past April, on the 40th anniversary of Dr. King's assassination, that McCain found himself in the uncomfortable position of trying to explain why he repeatedly voted against the bill for a National holiday in King's honor, so it's not like how he voted at the time wasn't fresh in his memory.)
McCain incorrectly cites Iraq as bordering Pakistan:
20.
Gaffe: During an interview on ABC's Good Morning America with Diane Sawyer, Senator McCain expressed concern over events "on the Iraq/Pakistan border". This would otherwise be a mild gaffe in that it is Iran and not Iraq that borders Pakistan. However, it achieves inclusion here because even if Senator McCain had correctly identified "Iran" as the country that borders Pakistan, the "situation" that both Sawyer and McCain are referring to are events on the Afghanistan/Pakistan border, not Iran (or Iraq).
McCain on Iraq as the source of the 2001 anthrax attack:
19.
Gaffe(warmongering?): On October 18, 2001, barely a month after the attacks of 9/11 and in the midst of the deadly anthrax scare where person(s) unknown had sent envelopes containing a powdered form of the deadly disease to members of Congress and the Media, Senator McCain appeared on "Late Night with David Letterman", where he accused Iraq as being the source of the attack:
LETTERMAN: "How are things going in Afghanistan now?"
McCAIN: " I think we’re doing fine …. I think we’ll do fine. The second phase — if I could just make one, very quickly — the second phase is Iraq. There is some indication, and I don’t have the conclusions, but some of this anthrax may — and I emphasize may — have come from Iraq."
LETTERMAN: "Oh, is that right?"
Barely a month after 9/11, McCain was already repeating Bush White House talking points to hype Iraq as an active threat to the United States despite having absolutely no evidence to support such a claim.
When the FBI revealed this week that the man believed to be the source of the 2001 anthrax attacks committed suicide rather than be arrested, McCain offered no retraction of his earlier accusation, and still, to this day, argues that Iraq was an active threat to the United States.
Flip: Senator McCain has repeatedly attacked Senator Obama on the issue of taxes, in one appearance saying (quote):
McCain: "The choice in this election is stark & simple. Senator Obama will raise your taxes; I won't."
Flop: During his interview on ABC's This Week, Senator McCain said that the possibility of raising taxes "to save Social Security" is an option he's willing to consider:
George S: "Is [sic] payroll tax increases on the table as well?"
McCain: "There’s nothing that’s off the table. I have my positions and I will articulate them, but nothing is off the table."
Flip-Flop: After angering the powerful Conservative group "Club for Growth", Senator McCain immediately recanted his assertion that he's willing to raise taxes to save Social Security.
(Editors Note: This is the fourth flip-flop/gaffe I have had to document in just the past 12 hours, three of them coming from the ABC "This Week" interview alone. Keeping up with "Senator Gaffe-machine" is shaping up to be a full-time job.)
Flip: During the Republican Primary Debate on May 3, 2007, Senator McCain reassured voters that he'd "follow bin Laden to the Gates of Hell" to capture him.
Flop: After having criticized Senator Obama for threatening to go into the Pakistani territory of Waziristan to get bin Laden if the Pakistani government failed to cooperate, Senator McCain was asked about whether he'd go into Pakistan to get bin Laden, during an interview on Larry King Live:
King: "If you were president and you knew that bin Laden was in Pakistan, and you knew where, would you have U.S. forces go in after him?"
McCain: "Larry, I'm not gonna go there and here's why: Pakistan is a sovereign nation. I think the Pakistanis want bin Laden out of their hair and out of their country, as causing great difficulties in Pakistan itself. But I want to assure you that I will get Osama bin Laden as President of the United States and I will bring him to justice no matter what it takes."
Editor's Note: While McCain may believe Pakistanis "want to be rid of bin Laden", one of the difficulties in obtaining actionable intelligence on his current whereabouts is the fact bin Laden is so beloved by the Pakistani people, no one is willing to give him up. To make matters worse, the Pakistani government declared Waziristan, the Northern border region with Afghanistan as a "demilitarized safe zone" off-limits to both the U.S. & Pakistani military.
Gaffe(?):During his interview on ABC's "This Week", McCain referred to the "Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General David Petraeus":
"I believe that, when he [Obama] said that we had to leave Iraq, and we had to be out by last March, and we had to have a date certain, that was in contravention to — and still is — the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General David Petraeus."
Now, it can be argued that Senator McCain was referring to BOTH Chairman of the JCS Mike Mullen AND General David Petraeus, but it certainly seems unlikely.
Flip: In 1998, the state legislature of McCain's home state of Arizona considered sending the voters a measure to end affirmative action, McCain spoke out against the measure calling it "divisive." Ten years later, Arizona Republicans are still trying to get the measure on the state ballot.
Flop:During his interview on the 7/26 edition of ABC's "This Week" (advance video to very end for his response), when asked specifically about the Arizona proposal, McCain stated that he "supports" the referendum to end affirmative action in the state of Arizona. He made the assertion in response to his "opposition to gay adoption", in which he implied that it was preferable for children to remain in orphanages rather than be adopted by a carefully screened gay couple.
During the January 30th, RNC Primary debate, former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney angrily responded to Senator McCain's charge that he advocated a "timetable" for withdrawal from Iraq: "I have never, ever supported a specific timetable" for withdrawing troops, Romney said. McCain's accusation on the eve of Tuesday's primary, he said, "sort of falls into the dirty tricks that I think Ronald Reagan would have found reprehensible."
April 7, 2008 - ...criticized his Democratic competitors, Senators Hillary Rodham Clinton and Barack Obama, for what he called a policy of "withdraw and re-invade" and for basing their positions on the war on political ambition.
July 9, 2008 - Sen. John McCain Wednesday suggested Sen. Barack Obama may alter his promise to withdraw US troops from Iraq within 16 months after meeting with US. General David Petraeus, the commander of US forces in Iraq.
"I'm glad that he is, for the first time, asking for a sit down briefing with Gen. Petraeus and I'll be very interested in what his position on Iraq is when he returns," McCain said during a satellite interview with ABC News' Charlie Gibson Wednesday from Pittsburgh.
July 17, 2008 - Republican presidential candidate John McCain on Thursday ridiculed Democrat Barack Obama's vow to withdraw U.S. troops from Iraq in 16 months as "a political tactic aimed at getting votes."
Floppity:July 21, 2008 - After Iraqi Prime Minister Maliki described Senator Obama's 16 month plan for withdrawal from Iraq as "the right timeframe for a withdrawal, with the possibility of slight changes", Senator McCain was asked what he thought of Maliki's advocacy of a 16-month timetable for withdrawal from Iraq:
"I think they could be largely withdrawn," citing the "success of the Surge" he advocated as making such a timetable possible.
Flop:July 26, 2008 - In an interview on CNN today -- which the DNC is passing around -- McCain said that withdrawal from Iraq in 16 months is "a pretty good timetable."
[...]
Of course, McCain did stress that such a withdrawal "would have to be based on conditions on the ground", which Senator Obama has ALWAYS stipulated in his plan for withdrawal.
Editor's Note: Notice how on July 9th, Senator McCain was predicting that Senator Obama's position would be the one to change after meeting with Gen. Petraeus
McCain on public speaking outside the U.S. during the campaign:
13.
Flip: Immediately following Senator Obama's speech before 200,000 cheering Berliners in Germany, Senator McCain criticized his opponent:
“I would rather speak at a rally or a political gathering any place outside of the country after I am president of the United States,” McCain told O’Donnell. “But that’s a judgment that Sen. Obama and the American people will make.”
Flop: Senator McCain forgets that just one month earlier on January 20th, he gave a speech paid for by his own campaign in neighboring Canada:
"McCain himself gave a speech in Canada — to the Economic Club of Canada — in which he applauded NAFTA’s successes. An implicit message behind that speech was that Obama had been critical of the trade accord."
NBC's Andrea Mitchell reported that McCain is criticizing Obama for "being overseas while voters are struggling at home" despite the fact Senator McCain himself just returned from campaign visits to both Mexico and Columbia earlier the same month.
McCain on Which came 1st? The Surge or the Awakening?:
12.
Gaffe: During an interview with CBS News' Katie Couric, Senator McCain was asked what he thought about Senator Obama's comment that the decline in violence in Iraq might very well be attributable to a number of other occurrences in Iraq, such as the "Sunni Awakening". Senator McCain scoffed at the notion, claiming the "Surge" was responsible for all those events, including the "Sunni Awakening":
"Couric QUESTION #3: Senator McCain, Sen. Obama says, while the increased number of U.S. troops contributed to increased security in Iraq, he also credits the Sunni awakening and the Shiite government going after militias. And says that there might have been improved security even without the surge. What’s your response to that?"
McCain (edited portion): "I don’t know how you respond to something that is such a false depiction of what actually happened. Colonel McFarlane (phonetic) was contacted by one of the major Sunni sheiks. Because of the surge we were able to go out and protect that sheik and others." (the full response can be seen in the linked video.)
Problem is, ALL of those events occurred BEFORE the Surge, not after.
In a highly controversial move, CBS broadcast McCain's comment with the preceding gaffe edited out and the enclosing comments spliced together to make it appear the gaffe never happened.
Gaffe: During a July 14th Town Hall meeting in his home state of Arizona, Senator McCain referred to the country of "Czechoslovakia", which has not existed since it was divided into the Czech Republic & Slovakia back in 1993. This alone would not be a big deal, if Senator McCain hadn't made reference to the non-existent country again just two days later during a Town Hall meeting in neighboring New Mexico.
While picking on a reference to the nonexistent "Czechoslovakia" in the space of two days may seem unfair, Presidential Candidate, Governor George W. Bush also caught the Senator making the same gaffe during the 2000 Presidential campaign:
"In early 2000, then-Gov. George W. Bush told Roger Simon, then with U.S. News & World Report, that he was befuddled by how soft the media was on Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz.
"I don't think there is any plot; I hope there isn't," Bush said. "But it's an amazing phenomenon, I'll tell you that. It's like the flap over the foreign-leader deal. A guy gets up and quizzes me -- it's my fault for trying to answer -- but John McCain says something about the 'ambassador to Czechoslovakia.' Well, I know there is no Czechoslovakia (there's a Czech Republic and a Slovakia), but yet it didn't make the nightly national news. I'm not going to gripe about it, but the media question is starting to pop up."
Yes, even George Bush knew there is no longer a "Czechoslovakia", but eight years later, John McCain is still saying there is.
McCain on Shifting troops from Iraq to Afghanistan:
10.
Flip: In response to Senator Obama calling "Afghanistan, not Iraq" as "the central front front on the War on Terror" requiring a redeployment of U.S. troops from Iraq to Afghanistan, Senator McCain balked at the idea, citing both General David Petraeus and "al Qaeda" as calling "Iraq, not Afghanistan" the "central front of the war on terror", and that America should focus on finishing the war in Iraq before diverting attention to Afghanistan.
Flop: Following reports of a sharp rise in U.S. troop casualties and a resurgent Taliban in Afghanistan, and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Mike Mullen stating that he "needs three additional brigades in Afghanistan", Senator McCain changed his position on diverting U.S. forces from Iraq to Afghanistan. McCain's website now says, the Arizona Republican wants "at least three additional brigades" for the fight in Afghanistan.
Flip: Following criticism of his Chief Economic Advisor, former Texas Senator Phil Gramm, who described the prevailing economic mood of the country as a "mental recession" rather than based on any valid reason for displeasure with the U.S. economy, followed by calling most Americans "a nation of whiners", Senator McCain disavowed Senator Gramm's remarks and accepted Gramm's resignation as an advisor to his campaign.
Flop: However, several videos of Senator McCain soon surfaced where he too referred to the current economic mood as being based more on "psychology" than the actual state of the economy.
Gaffe: During a press availability, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) said that he’s been concerned by “a couple of steps that the Russian government took in the last several day,” including “reducing the energy supplies to Czechoslovakia.” But, as TPM’s Greg Sargent points out, Czechoslovakia hasn’t existed in 15 years. This isn’t the first time McCain has made this mistake. At a debate in Oct. 2007, McCain said that America needs to “have a missile defense system in place in Czechoslovakia and Poland.”
Update Sargent notes that McCain also made the Czechoslovakia mix up about three months ago on Don Imus's radio show.
McCain on the U.S.'s economic relationship with Iran:
7.
Gaffe: During a candid moment speaking to reporters, Senator McCain made the following "joke" (video) in response to the news that U.S. exports to Iran increased tenfold while George W Bush was President:
REPORTER: "We've learned that exports to Iran increased by tenfold during the Bush Administration, the biggest export was cigarettes. Given that the, yeah... supposedly that the..."
McCAIN:(interrupting) "Maybe that's the way of killing them. (chuckles) I meant that as a joke."
Follow up: Iran responded to the Senator's "joke" the following Monday (7/14/08), kindly calling it “inappropriate” and “regretful.”
Flip: Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) participated in a town hall meeting in Wisconsin. During the discussion, he claimed that he is a strong supporter of equal pay for women and other workers:
"We haven’t done enough. We have not done enough. And I’m committed to making sure that there’s equal pay for equal work. That there is equal opportunity in every aspect of our society. And that is my record and you can count on it." - (video)
Flop: In April, McCain skipped the vote on the Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, which would have rectified the Supreme Court decision in Ledbetter v. Goodyear “that made it much harder for women and other workers to pursue pay discrimination claims.”
In fact, on that very same day, McCain said that if he had been in the Senate, he would have voted against it because the bill “opens us up to lawsuits for all kinds of problems.” He also dismissed the importance of equal pay, saying that women simply need “education and training“:
“They need the education and training, particularly since more and more women are heads of their households, as much or more than anybody else,” McCain said. “And it’s hard for them to leave their families when they don’t have somebody to take care of them.
The issue is not “education and training.” When denied equal pay by her supervisor, Lilly Ledbetter was doing the exact same job as her male counterparts and received numerous performance-based awards.
As [ThinkProgress'] Wonk Room notes, in 2000, McCain also opposed an amendment aimed at providing “more effective remedies to victims of discrimination in the payment of wages on the basis of sex.” In 1985, McCain voted against a study to investigate pay differences among federal employees and determine whether they were the result of discrimination.
In May, McCain told a 14-year-old girl that equal pay and legislation such as Ledbetter bill don’t do “anything to help the rights of women.” McCain, however, is no expert on women’s issues. He has earned a 0 percent rating from NARAL ProChoice America six years in a row, from 2001-2007.
McCain on Criticizing others for missing Senate votes:
5.
Gaffe: Following Iran’s missile tests this week, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) slammed Sen. Barack Obama’s (D-IL) position on the Iranian Revolutionary Guard, declaring, “This is the same organization that I voted to condemn as a terrorist organization when an amendment was on the floor of the United States Senate. Senator Obama refused to vote.” CNN’s Political Ticker notes a flaw with McCain’s attack:
The problem with the critique? McCain also missed that vote on the Kyl-Lieberman amendment on September 26, 2007. Records show that Obama was in New Hampshire and McCain was in New York instead of being in the Senate chamber for the vote in question.
Gaffe: In McCain’s best-selling 1999 memoir “Faith of My Fathers”, McCain writes:
"Once my condition had stabilized, my interrogators resumed their work. Demands for military information were accompanied by threats to terminate my medical treatment if I did not cooperate. Eventually, I gave them my ship’s name and squadron number, and confirmed that my target had been the power plant. Pressed for more useful information, I gave the names of the Green Bay Packers offensive line, and said they were members of my squadron. When asked to identify future targets, I simply recited the names of a number of North Vietnamese cities that had already been bombed." - ABC News
While visiting Pittsburgh, John McCain said that while he was captured, he really loved the Steelers, and it was their names that he gave up to Viet-Cong interrogators (video)
Gaffe: John McCain spoke in Colorado trying to sell his economic plan on Monday, referring to a Colorado shoe maker that President Bush himself referred to 18 months earlier as an example of an American Free-Trade success story:
"Five years ago, the outdoor footware company Crocs was started by a couple of entrepreneurs with a great idea, ingenuity and drive. This former small business now employs 600 people in Colorado alone and sells over 50% of its products in 90 countries around the world. Building barriers to Crocs or any American company’s access to foreign markets will have a devastating effect on our economy and jobs and the prosperity of American families."
Problem is, it's not true. Via OurFuture.org:
"Truth be told: Crocs weren't invented by "a couple of entrepreneurs" in Colorado, [...].They weren't even invented in America. They were invented in that Great Frozen Socialist Paradise to the north... Canada.
The company that invented them was subsequently bought by Hansen and two other aforementioned Colorado entrepreneurs, who added the cute name and the marketing gloss. But the shoes are still made abroad, in the original factory in Quebec, where the employees come pre-equipped with their own health insurance. Or at least, they will be for a few more weeks: in April, the company announced that they will close down the Quebec City plant in July, sending the 670 jobs there to plants in Mexico, Brazil, and beyond.
In other words: it's another Great American Business that does most of its business elsewhere. Six hundred U.S. jobs is a fine thing—but it could be twice that many if they were actually made here, too.
It's also not a robust business, at least not at the moment. Following a solid IPO in 2006 and a strong 2007, their sales have been off dramatically this year. [...]"
Flip: During a June 12th Town Hall in New Hampshire:
"If you want to call it [his proposal to temporarily suspend the gas tax, decried by most economists] a gimmick, fine. You know the economists? They’re the same ones that didn’t predict this housing crisis we’re in." [video]
Senior Advisor Carly Fiorina: During an appearance on ABC’s This Week, Fiorina “scoffed at the lack of support from economic analysts” for McCain’s proposed gas-tax holiday, “‘I don’t think it matters,’ she said.”
Senior Advisor Douglas Holtz-Eaken: “You can stack all the economists end to end and still not find common sense.”
Flop: The McCain campaign is announcing that the Senator's economic plan has been endorsed by some 300 economists:
"U.S. Senator John McCain’s presidential campaign today released a statement signed by over 300 professional economists in support of John McCain’s Jobs for America economic plan. The list includes Nobel Prize winners, business economists with experience in the private sector, policy economists with experience in government and academic economists from major universities and state and community colleges."
Not mentioned in the announcement is that two key factors in the McCain economic plan... his 'gas tax holiday' and promise to 'balance the budget by 2013"... were not included in the proposal given to the economists.
McCain on criticizing those who say "Military service not a requirement to be CIC":
1.
Flip: The McCain campaign, responding to Fmr. General Wesley Clark's suggestion that "[I don't think] getting shot down is a qualification to be President" after extensive mention of his respect for McCain's service, even calling McCain "a hero", issued the following statement:
The American people know that John McCain’s record of service and sacrifice is not a matter of debate. He has written about and discussed his service as a POW extensively — often in excruciating and painful detail. The American people will judge harshly anyone who demeans or attacks that service.
Flop: John McCain on "military service as a requirement to be President" during the 2000 and 2004 Presidential campaigns:
- During an interview with National Journal, John McCain was asked if “military service inherently makes somebody better equipped to be commander-in-chief.” McCain said, “Absolutely not… I absolutely don’t believe that it’s necessary.” [National Journal, 2/15/2003]
- I believe that military service is the most honorable endeavor an American may undertake.But I’ve never believed that lack of military service disqualifies one from occupying positions of political leadership or as Commander and Chief. In America, the people are sovereign, and they decide who is and is not qualified to lead us. [American Legion Speech, 9/7/1999]
- Earlier this year at Washington’s Gridiron Club, where humor is the required fare, McCain lay bare what underlies his candidacy. Wearing a jacket outlandishly festooned with dozens of fake military medals, McCain said, “The question I ask myself every morning while shaving in front of the mirror is: OK, John, you’re an incredible war hero, an inspiration to all Americans. But what qualifies you to be president of the United States?” [Minneapolis Star Tribune, 11/7/1999]
McCain on supporting the 1986 Immigration Reform Act:
20.
Gaffe: Speaking before NALEO (the National Association of Latino Elected and Appointed Officials), McCain stated:
"[I]n 1986, we passed a law and said we would secure the borders and gave amnesty to a couple — three million people. I supported that legislation way back then."
In actuality, McCain vocally opposed and voted against the 1986 Immigration Reform Act:
The Arizona Republic newspaper in 1986 reported that he had called the bill racist and quoted him as saying the bill’s requirements for employers to verify workers “would institutionalize discrimination.” He said employers would refuse to hire Hispanics to avoid running afoul of the law.
A McCain campaign official said the senator “was referring to his support for a comprehensive solution - going back to that time.
Gaffe: (via Crooks & Liars) The Huffington Post reported, McCain in an interview with the Las Vegas Sun headed for the gutter while trying to explain why he did not choose Republican Governor Jim Gibbons (now in the midst of a messy divorce and previously the subject of sexual assault allegations) as his Nevada campaign chair:
McCain: I appreciate his support. As you know, the lieutenant governor is our chairman.
Q: Why snub the governor?
McCain: I didn’t mean to snub him. I’ve known the lieutenant governor for 15 years and we’ve been good friends….I didn’t intend to snub him. There are other states where the governor is not the chairman.
Q: Maybe it’s the governor’s approval rating and you are running from him like you are from the president?
McCain: (Chuckling) And I stopped beating my wife just a couple of weeks ago…
...misquoting the "have you stopped beating your wife? Yes or No?" courtroom joke. A simple flubbed attempt at humor? Imagine the reaction if Senator Obama had said it.
Keep in mind that earlier this month (see general gaffe #2), McCain had to rescheule a Republican fundraiser that was scheduled at the home of Texas Millionaire Clayton Williams, who lost his 1990 Gubernatorial bid after comparing "rape" to "the weather". McCain's notorious temper has, according to aides & reporters present at the time, resulted in him telling his wife Cindy during his '92 re-election campaign:
At one point, Cindy playfully twirled McCain's hair and said, "You're getting a little thin up there." McCain's face reddened, and he responded, "At least I don't plaster on the makeup like a trollop, you c*nt."
Is this the man Hillary supporters would REALLY vote for over Senator Obama simply over sour-grapes?
McCain on Passage of the new "21st Century GI Bill"
18.
Flip: While Senator McCain says he supported "increasing benefits" for soldiers that have fought in the "War on Terror", he actively fought against passage of Senator Webb's new "21st Century GI Bill" on the following grounds:
“There are fundamental differences,” McCain told Politico. “He [Sen Webb] creates a new bureaucracy and new rules. His bill offers the same benefits whether you stay three years or longer. We want to have a sliding scale to increase retention." [CBS News - 4/30/08]
Flop: Despite not even showing up to vote (a common occurrence since hitting the campaign trail) on passage of the GI Bill (which passed 92-6), McCain still took credit for passage of the historic bill, telling a crowd of supporters:
"I'm happy to tell you that we probably agreed on an increase in educational benefits for our veterans..."
Ibid - Crooks & Liars
6/27/08
McCain On Terrorist threats helping Republican candidates:
17.
Flip: On June 23rd, Fortune Magazine released an interview with McCain's chief strategist Charlie Black who said that, like the assassination of Pakistani leader Bhutto last year, another terrorist attack on U.S. soil “would be a big advantage” for McCain. Senator McCain responded:
“If he said that, and I do not know the context, I strenuously disagree.”
Flop: But during President Bush's 2004 re-election campaign, McCain's response to Osama bin Laden's video taped message just days before the election was:
“I think it’s very helpful to President Bush,” said McCain, R-Ariz., while stumping in Stamford for U.S. Rep. Christopher Shays. “It focuses America’s attention on the war on terrorism. I’m not sure if it was intentional or not, but I think it does have an effect.” [AP, 10/30/04]
McCain criticizing the Supreme Court's "Boumediene" ruling on detainees.
16.
Gaffe:According to Time Magazine, Senator McCain criticized the Supreme Court's "Boumediene" verdict... allowing GiTMO detainees to challenge their imprisonment... during a June 13th New Jersey Town Hall with:
"30 of the people who have already been released from Guantanamo Bay have already tried to attack America again, one of them just a couple weeks ago, a suicide bomber in Iraq."
Problem is, it's not true. According to Seaton Hall Law, last July, the Defense Department had issued a retraction:
"The “30” number, however, was corrected in a DoD press release issued in July 2007, and a DoD document submitted to the House Foreign Relations Committee on May 20, 2008 abandons the claim entirely."
Flip: In response to Michelle Obama's comment that "For the first time in my adult life, I'm ["really"] proud of my country" ("really" being used in a second recitation later that same day), the wife of Senator John McCain responded at a campaign rally:
"I don know about you, but I'm PROUD of MY country!"
Flop: On June 14th, responding to a questioner at a town hall meeting in New York on "how to be proud of the country" with all that is happening today, Senator McCain responded:
"I’ll admit to you … that it’s tough in some respects. We have not always done things right and we mismanaged the war in Iraq very badly for nearly four years.”
Flop-flop: After MSNBC found a clip of her husband in an interview with Fox News earlier this year stating:
"I didn't really didn't love America until I was deprived of her company" (referring to his time as a Vietnam POW)
...wife Cindy continued to defend her attack on Michelle Obama's comment while defending her husbands own suggestion that he "didn't really didn't love America until..."
(Note: AmericaBlog... via the Huffington Post... is reporting that Senator McCain had made a near identical statement back in 1999, but lacks a confirming link):
"It wasn't until I was deprived of her company that I fell in love with America."
Flip-flip-flop: While Senator McCain has not admonished his wife for her attacks on Michelle Obama for saying the same thing he himself has said repeatedly, he did tell CNN's Dana Milbank at that same town hall one day earlier (June 13th):
[E]very candidate's wife "should be treated with respect, and if there's any disrespectful conduct on the part of anyone, those people should be rejected."
No word yet as to whether Senator McCain has "rejected" his own wife from his campaign. (special thanks to Democratic Underground's "Top 10" for the references.)
McCain on running a respectful campaign with "no negative attack ads":
14.
Flip: On Mar 11, 2008, McCain's campaign manger Rick Davis sent out a memo to reporters citing:
"It is critical, as we prepare to face off with whomever the Democrats select as their nominee, that we all follow John's lead and run a respectful campaign focused on the issues and values that are important to the American people.
...
Throughout his life John McCain has held himself to the highest standards and he will continue to run a respectful campaign based on the issues."
"I intend to wage this campaign and to govern this country in a way that they would be proud of me,"
...
McCain also said that if elected, he would attempt to govern in the same spirit...
Flip: Criticized Obama's support of a "windfall profits" tax on oil companies as "If the plan sounds familiar, that's because that was Jimmy Carter's big idea too! And a lot of good it did us."
Flop: Said he'd be "glad to look at the idea of a windfall profits tax" on oil companies during a speech to the Charlotte, NC Chamber of Commerce on May 5th.
Flip: During a campaign speech in Sioux City, Iowa along side former GOP rival Mike Huckabee, McCain stated, "I've never been for, quote, privatized Social Security. I never have been. I never will be."
Flop: During the 2004 campaign (11/18/04), McCain stated, "Without privatization, I don't see how you could possibly, overtime, make sure young Americans are able to receive Social Security benefits."
Flip: In the November 2007 issue of Foreign Affairs, McCain argued “we can also afford to spend more on national defense, which currently consumes less than four cents of every dollar that our economy generates - far less than what we spent during the Cold War.”
Flop: Facing the $2 trillion budgetary hole the McCain tax plan is forecast to produce (a sea of red ink even the Wall Street Journal noticed), Team McCain changed its tune. As Forbes scoffed in amazement:
“McCain’s top economic adviser, Doug Holtz-Eakin, blithely supposes that cuts in defense spending could make up for reducing the corporate tax rate from 35% to 25% and the subsequent shrinkage in federal revenues. Get that? The national security candidate wants to cut spending on our national security. Wait until the generals and the admirals hear that.”
Flip: During a February 15th rally in La Crosse, Wisconsin, “McCain promised he’d offer a balanced budget by the end of his first term.”
Flippity: Days later, McCain’s senior economic adviser Douglas Holtz-Eakin announced a deficit-ending target of 2017. In mid-April, Holtz-Eakin proclaimed, “I would like the next president not to talk about deficit reduction.” McCain, too, signaled the retreat from his first-term balance budget commitment, explaining to Chris Matthews on April 15th that “economic conditions are reversed.”
Flop: On June 6, Holtz-Eakin announced, “That plan, when appropriately phased in, as it has always been intended to be, will bring the budget to balance by the end of his first term.”
Flop: During his disastrous “green screen” speech on June 3, McCain reached out to Hillary Clinton’s supporters by proclaiming, “The media often overlooked how compassionately she spoke to the concerns and dreams of millions of Americans, and she deserves a lot more appreciation than she sometimes received.”
Flop:June 7, McCain denied to Newsweek that his critique of the media never passed his lips, “I did not–that was in prepared remarks, and I did not–I’m not in the business of commenting on the press and their coverage or not coverage.”
link - (Ibid)
6/3/08
McCain on The Estate Tax:
7.
Flip: On June 8, 2006, McCain on the Senate floor expressed his agreement with Teddy Roosevelt that “most great civilized countries have an income tax and an inheritance tax” and “in my judgment both should be part of our system of federal taxation.”
Flop:In a speech before small business owners in New York, McCain declared “the estate tax is one of the most unfair tax laws on the books.”
Flip: On December 20, 2007, McCain suggested to Pulitzer prize-winning journalist Charles Savage that President Bush had clearly crossed the line with his violation of the FISA Act. As Wired’s Ryan Singel noted:
“I think that presidents have the obligation to obey and enforce laws that are passed by Congress and signed into law by the president, no matter what the situation is,” McCain said. The Globe’s Charlie Savage pushed further, asking , “So is that a no, in other words, federal statute trumps inherent power in that case, warrantless surveillance?” To which McCain answered, “I don’t think the president has the right to disobey any law.”
Flippity:
On June 2, McCain adviser Holtz-Eakin put that notion to rest, telling the National Review:
“[N]either the Administration nor the telecoms need apologize for actions that most people, except for the ACLU and the trial lawyers, understand were Constitutional and appropriate in the wake of the attacks on September 11, 2001.”
Flop: Pressed to explain the glaring inconsistencies, John McCain on June 6 the New York Times reported McCain now believes the legality of Bush’s regime of NSA domestic surveillance is unclear and, in any event, is old news:
“It’s ambiguous as to whether the president acted within his authority or not,” he said, saying courts had ruled different ways on the matter. “I’m not interested in going back. I’m interested in addressing the challenge we face to day of trying to do everything we can to counter organizations and individuals that want to destroy this country. So there’s ambiguity about it. Let’s move forward.”
As for immunity for the telecommunications firms cooperating with the White House in what before August 2007 was doubtless illegal surveillance, there too McCain’s position has evolved. On May 23, campaign surrogate Chuck Fish announced that McCain would not back retroactive immunity “unless there were revealing Congressional hearings and heartfelt repentance from those telephone and internet companies.” Subsequently, the McCain campaign swiftly backtracked, claiming its man supports immunity unconditionally.
Flip: June 4, McCain tells a group of Florida newspaper editors, “I am in favor of doing whatever’s necessary to save the Everglades.”
Flop: McCain not only opposed $2 billion in funding for the restoration of the Everglades national park, he backed President Bush’s veto of the legislation in 2007. “I believe,” he said, “that we should be passing a bill that will authorize legitimate, needed projects without sacrificing fiscal responsibility.”
McCain on using sanctions as a tool of influencing international policy:
4.
Flip: During his June 2 speech to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), John McCain called for the international community to target Iran for the kind of worldwide sanctions regime applied to apartheid-era South Africa.
Flop: McCain advisers Charlie Black and Rick Davis each represented firms doing business with Tehran. Even more unfortunate, John McCain was frequently not among those offering “moral clarity and conviction” in backing “a divestment campaign against South Africa, helping to rid that nation of the evil of apartheid.” As ThinkProgress detailed:
Despite voting to override President Reagan’s veto of a bill imposing economic sanctions against South Africa in 1986, McCain voted against sanctions on at least six other occasions.
Flip: During the run-up to the Michigan primary, John McCain cautioned workers in January that he didn’t want to raise “false hopes that somehow we can bring back lost jobs,” adding that it” wasn’t government’s job to protect buggy factories and haberdashers when cars replaced carriages and men stopped wearing hats.”
Flippity:On April 22, 2008 in during a speech at Youngstown State University in Ohio, McCain told the crowd: "I can't tell you that these jobs are ever coming back to this magnificent part of the country,"
The Arizona senator said he believes Americans need to take advantage of opportunities of a new economy, not cling to the old economy. "I know that's small comfort to you, but I can't look you in the eye and tell you that those steel mills are coming back," he said.
Flop:On June 5:
echoing Mitt Romney who trounced him in the January 15th primary, McCain returned to Michigan, telling a local television station that he would fight for new jobs and the state wouldn't ``be left behind.'
Nowadays, the party’s presumptive nominee is singing a different tune, striking a populist pose and saying “new jobs are coming”… …Over the past few months, however, McCain has taken a lesson from Romney, acknowledging recently that “Americans are hurting.” Returning to Michigan last month, the Arizona senator told a local television station that he would fight for new jobs and the state wouldn’t “be left behind.”
Flip: During a June 4th town hall meeting in Baton Rouge, John McCain answered a reporter’s question regarding Hurricane Katrina and investigating the failure of the New Orleans levees by announcing:
“I’ve supported every investigation and ways of finding out what caused the tragedy. I’ve been here to New Orleans. I’ve met with people on the ground.”
Flop: In 2005 and 2006 McCain twice voted against a commission to study the government’s response to Katrina. He also opposed three separate emergency funding measures providing relief to Katrina victims, including the extension of five months of Medicaid benefits. Until traveling there one month ago, McCain had made just one public tour of New Orleans since Hurricane Katrina touched down in August 2005.
Flip: In a televised speech hoping to steal some of the thunder from Barack Obama's announcement that he had clinched the Democratic nomination, McCain said:
"You will hear from my opponent’s campaign in every speech, every interview, every press release that I’m running for President Bush’s third term. You will hear every policy of the President described as the Bush-McCain policy. Why does Senator Obama believe it’s so important to repeat that idea over and over again? Because he knows it’s very difficult to get Americans to believe something they know is false."
Flop: During his appearance on the June 19, 2005 edition of "Meet the Press", McCain responded to Tim Russert's claim, "The fact is you are different than George Bush.":
"No. No. I--the fact is that I'm different but the fact is that I have agreed with President Bush far more than I have disagreed. And on the transcendent issues, the most important issues of our day, I've been totally in agreement and support of President Bush."
link - Ibid
6/3/08
May
Comment
link
Date
McCain on the reason for the Iraq war:
2.
Gaffe: During a Town Hall meeting in Denver, CO., Senator McCain suggested that the war in Iraq was actually a war for oil:
"My friends, I will have an energy policy that we will be talking about, which will eliminate our dependence on oil from the Middle East that will prevent us from having ever to send our young men and women into conflict again in the Middle East."
Nothing bristles Conservatives more than the suggestion we went to war in Iraq, expending thousands of lives and billions of dollars, "for oil", a frequent charge by many Democrats. Senator McCain was forced to retract the suggestion within hours.
Flip: Speaking on the Senate floor in March 2006, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) argued for comprehensive immigration reform, stating that “while strengthening border security is an essential component of national security, it must also be accompanied by immigration reforms.”
Flop: But while seeking the GOP nomination for president, McCain “encountered anger from hard-line immigration foes,” particularly over his support for a bill that would “have allowed most undocumented immigrants to work toward citizenship.” Thus, in order to pander to the far right during the primary, McCain changed his position, saying the U.S. must secure the borders before undocumented immigrants are dealt with, thereby discarding the “comprehensive” nature of his previous immigration position:
[I] have pledged that it would be among my highest priorities to secure our borders first, and only after we achieved widespread consensus that our borders are secure, would we address other aspects of the problem in a way that defends the rule of law and does not encourage another wave of illegal immigration.
Flip: But now that McCain has all but locked up the nomination, he has to start dancing. Trying to court Latino voters, McCain flipped back to his original position, saying he now supports “comprehensive immigration reform“:
McCAIN: We get in this kind of a circular firing squad on immigration reform in the Congress of the United States, and the lesson I learned from it is we’ve got to have comprehensive immigration reform.
(UPDATE: On June 27, 2008, McCain praised himself for sponsoring the McCain-Kennedy immigration reform legislation of 2006). In a Jan. 30 GOP debate, McCain said he would not vote for his own bill today:
Q: At this point, if your original proposal came to a vote on the Senate floor, would you vote for it? […]
McCAIN: No, I would not, because we know what the situation is today. The people want the borders secured first.
Flip: During a February 2000 campaign stop in Virginia Beach, VA (hometown of Rev. Pat Robertson), Senator McCain referred to leaders of the Religious Right as "Agents of Intolerance":
"Neither party should be defined by pandering to the outer reaches of American politics and the agents of intolerance, whether they be Louis Farrakhan or Al Sharpton on the left, or Pat Robertson or Jerry Falwell on the right."
Flop: In an April 1, 2006 appearance on NBC's "Meet the Press", McCain declared that right-wing Rev. Jerry Falwell is no longer an “agent of intolerance,” as McCain described him in 2000:
RUSSERT: Do you believe that Jerry Falwell is still an agent of intolerance?
McCAIN: No, I don’t. I think that Jerry Falwell can explain to you his views on this program when you have him on."
Back in 2000, when McCain was asked whether he stood by his description of Falwell, he said, “I must not and will not retract anything that I said in that speech at Virginia Beach. It was carefully crafted, it was carefully thought out.” (Hardball, 3/1/00)
On May 13, 2006, McCain gave the Commencement address at Falwell's "Liberty University", where he was praised by Falwell, saying, "The ilk of John McCain is very scarce, very small."
Ibid
Ibid
McCain on his opposition to earmarks:
6.
Flip: In a TV ad entitled "Outrageous" that has been running since last November, Senator McCain addresses three specific examples of "pork" that passed in the U.S. Senate:
John McCain’s ad, “Outrageous,” which began running November 12 [...] claims that “one man” has “the guts to stand up to wasteful government spending.”
Flop: "But the three examples of spending highlighted in the ad – a “bridge to nowhere,” a study of bear DNA and a museum dedicated to Woodstock. [...] In fact, he voted in favor of the bill that included the bear study funding; he was absent for key votes on the Woodstock museum (including one on an amendment he co-sponsored); and he never specifically tried to eliminate the bridge earmark and missed some crucial votes on that one, as well."
Gaffe: Wanting to demonstrate just how much safer the streets of Iraq had become following his "Petraeus' Humvee" blunder, Senator McCain claimed that there “are neighborhoods in Baghdad where you and I could walk through those neighborhoods, today.”
But when he arrived, McCain was told that it was too unsafe for him to walk the streets without armed protection.
Only in full body armor, accompanied by “100 American soldiers, with three Blackhawk helicopters, and two Apache gunships overhead", was the Senator able to proceed with his photo-op.
(Editor's note: Despite taking place on April Fool's Day, McCain was quite serious and continued to defend his trip as proving his assertion.)
Flip: March 27th, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) told CNN that that President Bush’s escalation in Iraq is going so well, “General Petraeus goes out there almost every day in an unarmed Humvee.”
The next day, during an interview with McCain, CNN’s John Roberts rebutted McCain’s assertions, stating, “I checked with General Petraeus’s people overnight and they said he never goes out in anything less than an up-armored Humvee.”
Flop: Faced with overwhelming evidence that he was wrong, McCain denied he’d ever said it: “Well, I’m not saying they could go without protection. The President goes around America with protection. So, certainly I didn’t say that.”
Flip: A former POW himself who was tortured after his plane was shot down in Vietnam, Senator McCain quite vocally voiced his opposition to the use of torture by the U.S. on its own POW's held in sites such as "Abu Ghraib" and "Gitmo", on the floor of the U.S. Senate:
“It’s not about who THEY are, it’s about who WE are!” - 2005
Senator McCain has related both in his own auto-biography and before the cameras of how he "would of said anything to get them to stop torturing him" and related how he "gave up the names of the entire 1965 Green Bay Packers starting line" when asked for the names of fellow pilots in his squadron.
Flop: In the race to become the nominee of his Party for President, McCain's vocal opposition to the use of "torture" was unpopular among his constituents. So when a vote to ban the practice came before the newly Democratic Congress, McCain opposed the bill on the grounds that "the CIA" (specifically) should be allowed to continue to use torture. Despite McCain's opposition, the bill passed 51-45.
Flip: Opposed George Bush's proposed "tax cuts for the wealthy" during the 2000 Presidential campaign:
"I don’t believe the wealthiest 10% of Americans should get 60% of the tax breaks. I think the lowest 10% should get the breaks." - 1/5/00
again in 2001: “I am disappointed that the Senate Finance Committee preferred instead to cut the top tax rate of 39.6% to 36%, thereby granting generous tax relief to the wealthiest individuals of our country at the expense of lower- and middle-income American taxpayers.” - 5/21/01
And again in 2003: “But when you look at the percentage of the tax cuts that–as the previous tax cuts–that go to the wealthiest Americans, you will find that the bulk of it, again, goes to wealthiest Americans.” - 1/7/03
Flop:During an Interview on ABC's "This Week with George Stephanopoulos", McCain debated the term "wealthy"
(Making "finger-quotes in the air) "Oh, yes, sure, the wealthy, the wealthy. Always be interested in when people talk about who the, quote, “wealthy” are in America. I find it interesting."
Flip: (from CNN Money) When McCain ran for president in 1999 and 2000, he barely campaigned in Iowa, knowing that his anti-ethanol stance wouldn't cut it in corn country.
Four years later, McCain hadn't changed his tune. "Ethanol is a product that would not exist if Congress didn't create an artificial market for it. No one would be willing to buy it," McCain said in November 2003. "Yet thanks to agricultural subsidies and ethanol producer subsidies, it is now a very big business - tens of billions of dollars that have enriched a handful of corporate interests - primarily one big corporation, ADM. Ethanol does nothing to reduce fuel consumption, nothing to increase our energy independence, nothing to improve air quality."
Flop: "I support ethanol and I think it is a vital, a vital alternative energy source not only because of our dependency on foreign oil but its greenhouse gas reduction effects," he said in an August speech in Grinnell, Iowa.
"Today, for example, 1.3 million people in the world make a living off eBay, most of those are in the United State of America."
The astute among you may remember Vice President Dick Cheney citing ebay sales as a sign of a healthy economy during his 2004 re-election campaign:
"That's a source that didn't even exist 10 years ago," Cheney said, according to the Associated Press. "Four hundred thousand people make some money trading on eBay."
4.
As David Corn reported in Salon, John McCain back in 1998 used the occasion of a Republican Senate fundraiser to slander President Clinton's daughter and attorney general. Following in the proud tradition of Rush Limbaugh (who in 1993 called the young Chelsea "a dog"), Mr. Straight Talk joked:
"Why is Chelsea Clinton so ugly? Because her father is Janet Reno."
"I'd love to see a point where it is irrelevant, and could be repealed because abortion is no longer necessary. But certainly in the short term, or even the long term, I would not support repeal of Roe v. Wade, which would then force X number of women in America to [undergo] illegal and dangerous operations."
In a 2006 interview on ABC's "This Week", McCain stated:
"I don't think a constitutional amendment is probably going to take place, but I do believe that it's very likely or possible that the Supreme Court should - could overturn Roe v. Wade, which would then return these decisions to the states, which I support."
But by 2008, it is back to:
"I'm a federalist. Just as I believe that the issue of gay marriage should be decided by the states, so do I believe that we would be better off by having Roe v. Wade return to the states. And I don't believe the Supreme Court should be legislating in the way that they did on Roe v. Wade."
Randi Rhodes' "top-of-my-head" list of McCain flip flops:
8/7/08
He’s FOR Off shore drilling, after being against it for 26 YEARS.
He was Against Torture, now he’s for it.
Against Warrantless Wiretapping now he’s for it.
Against Tax Cuts, then for tax cuts, then against tax cuts and now is FOR RAISING FICA taxes.
Against Privitizing Social Security and now he’s FOR it.
FOR protecting Abortion Rights now he’s against it.
Against storing Nuclear Waste at Yucca Mountain now he’s for it.
Against engaging in diplomacy with Hamas now he’s for it. Against diplomacy in Syria now he’s for it. Against going after Al Qaeda in Pakistan now he’s for it. Against talking to Iran and now he’s for it. Against talking to North Korea and now he’s for it. For Liberman-Warner to curb Global Warming now he’s Against it. Both FOR and AGAINST attacking Obamas’ former Pastor. Against inflating your tires and getting a tune up, now he’s for it. FOR disclosure of campaign donations, now he’s against it. For the Iraq War because it would be quick and easy now against anyone who said Iraq would be quick and easy. Thought we were on the RIGHT COURSE in Iraq in 2004 now says he’s always been against Rumsfelds strategy in Iraq. FOR gay marriage now he’s against it. For Affirmative Action until he was against it. Against a timetable for withdrawal until he was for it, For the troops until he voted repeatedly against their body armor, helmets, vest inserts, R&R at home after a one year deployment and Senator Webb’s GI Bill.